Skip to main content

Unit 6 · Topic 6.5

6.5 Revising a thesis when new evidence appears

As you read more sources, you'll often find evidence that doesn't fit your first claim. Strong writers don't hide that evidence. They revise the thesis and the line of reasoning so the argument matches what the evidence actually shows.

Key terms

  • thesis
  • working thesis
  • revision
  • line of reasoning
  • defensible claim

Start with a working thesis

A working thesis is your best answer so far, written down so you can test it. It's supposed to change. Writing one early helps you read sources with a purpose: for each source, ask whether it supports, complicates or contradicts what you've written.

Contradicting evidence is useful, not a disaster. It tells you where your claim is too broad, too simple or missing a condition.

Ways to revise a thesis

RevisionWhen to use itExample
Narrow itEvidence shows the claim holds only for some people or placesAll schools should ... → High schools should ...
Add a conditionEvidence shows it works only under certain circumstances... should ban phones → ... should ban phones during class, as long as families can reach students in emergencies
Qualify the strengthEvidence is suggestive, not certain... will fix ... → ... can reduce ...
Change the reasonYour claim survives but your first reason doesn't... because it saves money → ... because it improves health
Change your positionMost of the evidence points the other waySwitch sides and use your old reasons as the counterargument

Revise the line of reasoning too

Your line of reasoning is the order of claims that lead to your thesis (3.4). When the thesis changes, check each body paragraph. A paragraph that supported the old thesis may now need a new topic sentence, a new place in the order, or a new job, such as handling the counterargument.

A quick check: read only your thesis and your topic sentences. They should form a short argument that makes sense on its own. If one topic sentence no longer leads to the thesis, revise it or cut the paragraph.

Revising under time pressure

On the synthesis essay, read all six sources before you commit to a final thesis. A thesis you write after reading everything is less likely to need emergency surgery halfway through the essay. If you realize mid-essay that your claim is too broad, you can still add a qualifier to the thesis sentence rather than starting over.

Multiple-choice writing questions also test this skill. You may see a draft paragraph plus a new piece of information and be asked how the writer should revise a claim to account for it. The best answer usually adjusts the claim's scope or adds a condition instead of ignoring the new information or abandoning the argument.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Revising after a contradicting source

    Working thesis: "Schools should replace all homework with in-class practice, because homework doesn't help students learn." New source (written for this practice set; invented): A summary of studies reports that homework shows little benefit for elementary students but a modest benefit for high school students when assignments are short and directly connected to class. Revise the thesis and say what happens to the line of reasoning.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Find the conflict. The thesis says homework doesn't help anyone, but the source shows a benefit for high school students under certain conditions.
    2. Step 2: Decide what survives. The evidence still supports cutting homework for younger students and cutting long, disconnected assignments.
    3. Step 3: Narrow and add a condition rather than abandoning the argument.
    4. Step 4: Update the paragraphs. The paragraph claiming homework never works must change; it could become the concession paragraph that admits the high school benefit and uses it to argue for short, targeted assignments.

    Answer: Revised thesis: "Elementary schools should replace most homework with in-class practice, and high schools should keep only short assignments tied directly to that day's lesson, because those are the only kinds of homework the evidence shows to be worth students' time." The old "homework never helps" paragraph becomes a concession that supports the new condition.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring evidence that doesn't fit. Readers notice, and on the synthesis essay the contradicting source is often there on purpose.
  • Revising the thesis but not the body paragraphs, so the essay argues something different from what the introduction promises.
  • Over-qualifying until the thesis takes no position. A revised thesis still has to be defensible and clear.

On the exam

  • A thesis with a clear condition or limit ("..., at least for...") often reads as more thoughtful, and it can set up a line of reasoning that earns the sophistication point.
  • Writing questions may give you a new fact and ask how to adjust a claim. Choose the revision that fits the new evidence while keeping the writer's main point.

Connected topics

Videos

  • How to Fix Your Thesis and Make it Defensible | AP Lang | Coach Hall Writes

    Coach Hall WritesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Revising your Thesis with a Checklist

    SNHU Academic SupportWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Write the AP Lang Synthesis Essay: Write a Thesis

    Marco LearningWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • NEVER STRUGGLE with ANY Synthesis Thesis (EVER)!

    Garden of EnglishWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Write a STRONG Thesis Statement | Scribbr 🎓

    ScribbrWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 6.5 Revising a thesis when new evidence appears

4 questions on 6.5 Revising a thesis when new evidence appears. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
(1) Across the country, a growing number of school districts have moved to a four-day school week, and our district’s board will vote on the idea this spring. (2) Under the plan, students would attend school Tuesday through Friday, with slightly longer days to make up the lost time. (3) The board should adopt a four-day week because it would save money and help the district hire teachers.
Paragraph 2
(4) The district currently spends heavily on buses, heating and substitute teachers, and those costs have risen faster than state funding for three years in a row. (5) According to a state audit of districts that switched, transportation and utility costs fell by an average of 5 percent (Source A). (6) For our district, that would mean roughly $400,000 a year that could go back into classrooms. (7) Supporters also say a longer weekend gives families more time together and gives students time for jobs, appointments and rest. (8) For example, one parent wrote on her blog that her children are “happier and less exhausted” since their district switched (Source B).
Paragraph 3
(9) A four-day week could also make the district more attractive to teachers. (10) Rural districts like ours often lose teachers to larger districts nearby that can pay several thousand dollars more each year. (11) In a survey of 300 teachers in our region, 68 percent said a four-day schedule would make them more likely to apply for a job (Source C).
Paragraph 4
(12) Some people worry that students will learn less. (13) However, students can simply use the extra day to catch up on their own. (14) Others worry that working parents will struggle to find child care on Mondays. (15) Many families already have relatives or neighbors who can help, and the local YMCA has said it might offer a Monday program.
Paragraph 5
(16) Overall, the four-day week is a smart change. (17) The board should approve it.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of a synthesis essay, which cites sources by letter. The district and the sources are invented.

Question 1 of 4

Sentence 3 is reproduced below. The board should adopt a four-day week because it would save money and help the district hire teachers. The writer then reads Source D, a study finding that students in four-day districts scored slightly lower in math than similar students in five-day districts, mostly where the fifth day offered no organized activities. Which version of sentence 3 best accounts for this new evidence?

Question 2 of 4

Sentence 13 waves away a serious concern. The writer has since read Source D, which found slightly lower math scores in four-day districts, mostly where the fifth day offered no organized activities. Which revision of sentence 13 best responds to the concern with evidence instead of an assumption?

Question 3 of 4

Suppose the writer has revised the thesis to say that the board should adopt the four-day week only if it offers tutoring and activities on the fifth day. Which version of sentences 16 and 17 best fits that thesis?

Paragraph 1
A shipowner was about to send to sea an emigrant-ship. He knew that she was old, and not over-well built at the first; that she had seen many seas and climes, and often had needed repairs. Doubts had been suggested to him that possibly she was not seaworthy. These doubts preyed upon his mind, and made him unhappy; he thought that perhaps he ought to have her thoroughly overhauled and refitted, even though this should put him to great expense. Before the ship sailed, however, he succeeded in overcoming these melancholy reflections. He said to himself that she had gone safely through so many voyages and weathered so many storms that it was idle to suppose she would not come safely home from this trip also. He would put his trust in Providence, which could hardly fail to protect all these unhappy families that were leaving their fatherland to seek for better times elsewhere. He would dismiss from his mind all ungenerous suspicions about the honesty of builders and contractors. In such ways he acquired a sincere and comfortable conviction that his vessel was thoroughly safe and seaworthy; he watched her departure with a light heart, and benevolent wishes for the success of the exiles in their strange new home that was to be; and he got his insurance-money when she went down in mid-ocean and told no tales.
Paragraph 2
What shall we say of him? Surely this, that he was verily guilty of the death of those men. It is admitted that he did sincerely believe in the soundness of his ship; but the sincerity of his conviction can in no wise help him, because he had no right to believe on such evidence as was before him. He had acquired his belief not by honestly earning it in patient investigation, but by stifling his doubts. And although in the end he may have felt so sure about it that he could not think otherwise, yet inasmuch as he had knowingly and willingly worked himself into that frame of mind, he must be held responsible for it.
Paragraph 3
Let us alter the case a little, and suppose that the ship was not unsound after all; that she made her voyage safely, and many others after it. Will that diminish the guilt of her owner? Not one jot. When an action is once done, it is right or wrong for ever; no accidental failure of its good or evil fruits can possibly alter that. The man would not have been innocent, he would only have been not found out. The question of right or wrong has to do with the origin of his belief, not the matter of it; not what it was, but how he got it; not whether it turned out to be true or false, but whether he had a right to believe on such evidence as was before him.
Paragraph 4
There was once an island in which some of the inhabitants professed a religion teaching neither the doctrine of original sin nor that of eternal punishment. A suspicion got abroad that the professors of this religion had made use of unfair means to get their doctrines taught to children. They were accused of wresting the laws of their country in such a way as to remove children from the care of their natural and legal guardians; and even of stealing them away and keeping them concealed from their friends and relations. A certain number of men formed themselves into a society for the purpose of agitating the public about this matter. They published grave accusations against individual citizens of the highest position and character, and did all in their power to injure these citizens in the exercise of their professions. So great was the noise they made, that a Commission was appointed to investigate the facts; but after the Commission had carefully inquired into all the evidence that could be got, it appeared that the accused were innocent. Not only had they been accused on insufficient evidence, but the evidence of their innocence was such as the agitators might easily have obtained, if they had attempted a fair inquiry. After these disclosures the inhabitants of that country looked upon the members of the agitating society, not only as persons whose judgment was to be distrusted, but also as no longer to be counted honourable men. For although they had sincerely and conscientiously believed in the charges they had made, yet they had no right to believe on such evidence as was before them. Their sincere convictions, instead of being honestly earned by patient inquiring, were stolen by listening to the voice of prejudice and passion.

William Kingdon Clifford, “The Ethics of Belief,” first published in the Contemporary Review (January 1877) and reprinted in his Lectures and Essays (1879), from the opening of section I, “The Duty of Inquiry.” Clifford, an English mathematician and philosopher, wrote the essay to argue that people have a moral duty to examine the evidence for what they believe. An “emigrant-ship” carried families leaving their homeland to settle abroad; “Providence” means God’s care; in paragraph 4, “professors” of a religion are people who profess, or openly follow, it. Clifford’s italics are not reproduced. Text from Wikisource, checked against the 1879 printing on archive.org.

Question 4 of 4

The primary purpose of the passage is to

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.