Skip to main content

Unit 9 · Topic 9.1

9.1 Joining an ongoing conversation

Most issues were being argued long before you arrived, so a strong argument responds to positions people have already taken. As you gather sources, sort them by whether they support your thesis, complement it by adding something new, or contradict it. That map of the conversation tells you where your own argument fits.

Key terms

  • conversation
  • discourse
  • position
  • support
  • complement
  • contradict

Arguments are part of a conversation

Think of an issue as a long conversation at a crowded table. People have already made claims, offered evidence and answered each other. If you walk up and repeat what someone said an hour ago, or ignore what everyone's been saying, no one will take you seriously. To join well, you listen first, then respond to what's actually been said.

In writing, that means showing readers which positions already exist and how yours relates to them. Do you agree with one side and add a new reason? Do you think both sides are missing something? Do you accept a common view but limit where it applies? Your thesis is more interesting when readers can see what it's responding to.

Support, complement, contradict

Every piece of evidence or source relates to your thesis in one of three ways:

RelationshipWhat it meansHow you use it
SupportsBacks up your claim directlyAs evidence in a body paragraph
ComplementsAdds a different angle, reason or example that fits with your claim without repeating itTo broaden your line of reasoning or add a new kind of evidence
ContradictsPushes against your claimTo concede, rebut or refute (9.2, 9.3), or as a reason to revise your thesis (6.5)

Mapping the conversation

Before you write, especially on the synthesis essay, make a quick map. For each source, jot its position and a word or two about its perspective (6.3). Then group the sources: which ones agree, which add new dimensions, which disagree? You'll often find that the disagreement isn't really "for" versus "against," but about a specific point: cost, fairness, who benefits.

That specific point of disagreement is where your argument can do the most work. A thesis that takes a position on the real point of tension, instead of the broad yes-or-no question, shows you understand the conversation. Exploring those tensions across the sources is one of the ways to earn the sophistication point.

Joining the conversation on the argument essay

The argument essay doesn't give you sources, but the conversation still exists. You can bring it in through what you know: how people have commonly argued about the issue, a historical debate, a well-known example. Briefly showing the usual positions, then explaining where yours fits, makes even a short timed essay feel like it's responding to something real.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Sorting sources and entering the conversation

    Practice sources (written for this practice set; all invented), on whether a city should close part of its downtown to cars on weekends. Your working thesis: The city should close Main Street to cars on weekends. Source A: A survey of downtown shop owners after a trial car-free weekend found most reported higher sales. Source B: A public health researcher notes that people walk more when streets are pleasant and safe. Source C: A disability rights group warns that closures make it hard for people who can't walk far to reach downtown businesses. Source D: A city traffic study finds that weekend traffic on Main Street is light compared with weekdays. Label each source as supporting, complementing or contradicting the thesis. Then write two sentences that enter the conversation.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: A directly supports the thesis: businesses benefit, which answers a common worry.
    2. Step 2: B complements it: it adds a different reason, health, that the business argument doesn't cover.
    3. Step 3: D supports it in a narrower way: weekends are the time a closure would disrupt the least traffic.
    4. Step 4: C contradicts it, at least in its current form. It raises a fairness issue the thesis ignores.
    5. Step 5: Find the real point of tension: not "cars versus no cars" but access for everyone. Use C to sharpen the thesis rather than ignore it.
    6. Step 6: Write an opening that names the usual debate and shows where your position fits.

    Answer: A supports, B complements, C contradicts, D supports. Model sentences: "Debates over car-free streets usually pit shop owners against drivers, but the trial weekend suggests that businesses gain more than they lose (Source A), and the more pressing question is who can still get downtown. The city should close Main Street to cars on weekends, as long as it keeps drop-off zones and shuttle access at each end, so that people who cannot walk long distances can still reach the businesses they rely on (Source C)."

Common mistakes

  • Writing as if your position is the first anyone has thought of. Show what others have said, then respond.
  • Treating every source as simply "for" or "against." Many sources complement your thesis by adding a new angle.
  • Leaving contradicting sources out of your essay. On the synthesis essay, a contradicting source is often your best chance to show complex thinking.

On the exam

  • On the synthesis essay, a thesis that responds to the specific point of tension among the sources usually leads to a more nuanced line of reasoning.
  • Reading questions may ask how a source or paragraph relates to the writer's claim: does it support, extend or challenge it? Check the logical relationship, not just the topic.

Connected topics

Videos

Check yourself: 9.1 Joining an ongoing conversation

4 questions on 9.1 Joining an ongoing conversation. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
I would say to them: You consider yourselves a reasonable and a just people; and I consider that in the general qualities of reason and justice you are not inferior to any other people. Still, when you speak of us Republicans, you do so only to denounce us as reptiles, or, at the best, as no better than outlaws. You will grant a hearing to pirates or murderers, but nothing like it to “Black Republicans.” In all your contentions with one another, each of you deems an unconditional condemnation of “Black Republicanism” as the first thing to be attended to. Indeed, such condemnation of us seems to be an indispensable prerequisite—license, so to speak—among you to be admitted or permitted to speak at all. Now, can you or not be prevailed upon to pause and to consider whether this is quite just to us, or even to yourselves? Bring forward your charges and specifications, and then be patient long enough to hear us deny or justify.
Paragraph 2
You say we are sectional. We deny it. That makes an issue; and the burden of proof is upon you. You produce your proof; and what is it? Why, that our party has no existence in your section—gets no votes in your section. The fact is substantially true; but does it prove the issue? If it does, then, in case we should, without change of principle, begin to get votes in your section, we should thereby cease to be sectional. You cannot escape this conclusion; and yet, are you willing to abide by it? If you are, you will probably soon find that we have ceased to be sectional, for we shall get votes in your section this very year. You will then begin to discover, as the truth plainly is, that your proof does not touch the issue. The fact that we get no votes in your section is a fact of your making, and not of ours.
Paragraph 3
And if there be fault in that fact, that fault is primarily yours, and remains so until you show that we repel you by some wrong principle or practice. If we do repel you by any wrong principle or practice, the fault is ours; but this brings you to where you ought to have started—to a discussion of the right or wrong of our principle. If our principle, put in practice, would wrong your section for the benefit of ours, or for any other object, then our principle, and we with it, are sectional, and are justly opposed and denounced as such. Meet us, then, on the question of whether our principle, put in practice, would wrong your section; and so meet us as if it were possible that something may be said on our side. Do you accept the challenge? No! Then you really believe that the principle which “our fathers who framed the government under which we live” thought so clearly right as to adopt it, and indorse it again and again, upon their official oaths, is in fact so clearly wrong as to demand your condemnation without a moment’s consideration.
Paragraph 4
Some of you delight to flaunt in our faces the warning against sectional parties given by Washington in his Farewell Address. Less than eight years before Washington gave that warning he had, as President of the United States, approved and signed an act of Congress enforcing the prohibition of slavery in the Northwestern Territory, which act embodied the policy of the government upon that subject up to and at the very moment he penned that warning; and about one year after he penned it, he wrote Lafayette that he considered that prohibition a wise measure, expressing in the same connection his hope that we should at some time have a confederacy of free States.
Paragraph 5
Bearing this in mind, and seeing that sectionalism has since arisen upon this same subject, is that warning a weapon in your hands against us, or in our hands against you? Could Washington himself speak, would he cast the blame of that sectionalism upon us, who sustain his policy, or upon you, who repudiate it? We respect that warning of Washington, and we commend it to you, together with his example pointing to the right application of it.
Paragraph 6
[. . .] Again, you say we have made the slavery question more prominent than it formerly was. We deny it. We admit that it is more prominent, but we deny that we made it so. It was not we, but you, who discarded the old policy of the fathers. We resisted, and still resist, your innovation; and thence comes the greater prominence of the question. Would you have that question reduced to its former proportions? Go back to that old policy. What has been will be again, under the same conditions. If you would have the peace of the old times, readopt the precepts and policy of the old times.

Abraham Lincoln, from an address delivered at the Cooper Institute (now Cooper Union) in New York City on February 27, 1860. Lincoln, an Illinois lawyer and a leader of the new Republican Party, which opposed the spread of slavery into the western territories, was seeking the party’s nomination for president. Many Southerners denounced the party as “sectional,” meaning that it served only the North, and called its members “Black Republicans” as an insult. Near the end of the speech, Lincoln turned to address “a few words to the Southern people,” though, as he said, he supposed they would not listen. The Northwestern Territory was the region north of the Ohio River, where a 1787 law banned slavery. The bracketed ellipsis marks omitted text. Text from Speeches & Letters of Abraham Lincoln, 1832–1865 (1907), Project Gutenberg eBook #14721.

Question 1 of 4

In paragraph 1, Lincoln grants that the Southern people are “not inferior to any other people” in “reason and justice” primarily in order to

Paragraph 1
Whatever people believe, on subjects on which it is of the first importance to believe rightly, they ought to be able to defend against at least the common objections. But, some one may say, “Let them be taught the grounds of their opinions. It does not follow that opinions must be merely parroted because they are never heard controverted. Persons who learn geometry do not simply commit the theorems to memory, but understand and learn likewise the demonstrations; and it would be absurd to say that they remain ignorant of the grounds of geometrical truths, because they never hear any one deny, and attempt to disprove them.” Undoubtedly: and such teaching suffices on a subject like mathematics, where there is nothing at all to be said on the wrong side of the question. The peculiarity of the evidence of mathematical truths is, that all the argument is on one side. There are no objections, and no answers to objections. But on every subject on which difference of opinion is possible, the truth depends on a balance to be struck between two sets of conflicting reasons. Even in natural philosophy, there is always some other explanation possible of the same facts; some geocentric theory instead of heliocentric, some phlogiston instead of oxygen; and it has to be shown why that other theory cannot be the true one: and until this is shown, and until we know how it is shown, we do not understand the grounds of our opinion. But when we turn to subjects infinitely more complicated, to morals, religion, politics, social relations, and the business of life, three-fourths of the arguments for every disputed opinion consist in dispelling the appearances which favour some opinion different from it. The greatest orator, save one, of antiquity, has left it on record that he always studied his adversary’s case with as great, if not with still greater, intensity than even his own. What Cicero practised as the means of forensic success, requires to be imitated by all who study any subject in order to arrive at the truth. He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that. His reasons may be good, and no one may have been able to refute them. But if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side; if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no ground for preferring either opinion. The rational position for him would be suspension of judgment, and unless he contents himself with that, he is either led by authority, or adopts, like the generality of the world, the side to which he feels most inclination.
Paragraph 2
[. . .] To abate the force of these considerations, an enemy of free discussion may be supposed to say, that there is no necessity for mankind in general to know and understand all that can be said against or for their opinions by philosophers and theologians. That it is not needful for common men to be able to expose all the misstatements or fallacies of an ingenious opponent. That it is enough if there is always somebody capable of answering them, so that nothing likely to mislead uninstructed persons remains unrefuted. That simple minds, having been taught the obvious grounds of the truths inculcated on them, may trust to authority for the rest, and being aware that they have neither knowledge nor talent to resolve every difficulty which can be raised, may repose in the assurance that all those which have been raised have been or can be answered, by those who are specially trained to the task.
Paragraph 3
Conceding to this view of the subject the utmost that can be claimed for it by those most easily satisfied with the amount of understanding of truth which ought to accompany the belief of it; even so, the argument for free discussion is no way weakened. For even this doctrine acknowledges that mankind ought to have a rational assurance that all objections have been satisfactorily answered; and how are they to be answered if that which requires to be answered is not spoken? or how can the answer be known to be satisfactory, if the objectors have no opportunity of showing that it is unsatisfactory? If not the public, at least the philosophers and theologians who are to resolve the difficulties, must make themselves familiar with those difficulties in their most puzzling form; and this cannot be accomplished unless they are freely stated, and placed in the most advantageous light which they admit of.

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859), from Chapter II, “Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion.” The bracketed ellipsis marks omitted text.

Question 2 of 4

Mill’s reference in paragraph 1 to “the greatest orator, save one, of antiquity” primarily serves to

Question 3 of 4

In context, Mill’s claim “He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that” most nearly means that

Paragraph 1
Complaints are everywhere heard from our most considerate and virtuous citizens, equally the friends of public and private faith, and of public and personal liberty, that our governments are too unstable, that the public good is disregarded in the conflicts of rival parties, and that measures are too often decided, not according to the rules of justice and the rights of the minor party, but by the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority. However anxiously we may wish that these complaints had no foundation, the evidence, of known facts will not permit us to deny that they are in some degree true. It will be found, indeed, on a candid review of our situation, that some of the distresses under which we labor have been erroneously charged on the operation of our governments; but it will be found, at the same time, that other causes will not alone account for many of our heaviest misfortunes; and, particularly, for that prevailing and increasing distrust of public engagements, and alarm for private rights, which are echoed from one end of the continent to the other. These must be chiefly, if not wholly, effects of the unsteadiness and injustice with which a factious spirit has tainted our public administrations.
Paragraph 2
[. . .] There are two methods of curing the mischiefs of faction: the one, by removing its causes; the other, by controlling its effects.
Paragraph 3
There are again two methods of removing the causes of faction: the one, by destroying the liberty which is essential to its existence; the other, by giving to every citizen the same opinions, the same passions, and the same interests.
Paragraph 4
It could never be more truly said than of the first remedy, that it was worse than the disease. Liberty is to faction what air is to fire, an aliment without which it instantly expires. But it could not be less folly to abolish liberty, which is essential to political life, because it nourishes faction, than it would be to wish the annihilation of air, which is essential to animal life, because it imparts to fire its destructive agency.
Paragraph 5
The second expedient is as impracticable as the first would be unwise. As long as the reason of man continues fallible, and he is at liberty to exercise it, different opinions will be formed. As long as the connection subsists between his reason and his self-love, his opinions and his passions will have a reciprocal influence on each other; and the former will be objects to which the latter will attach themselves. The diversity in the faculties of men, from which the rights of property originate, is not less an insuperable obstacle to a uniformity of interests. The protection of these faculties is the first object of government. From the protection of different and unequal faculties of acquiring property, the possession of different degrees and kinds of property immediately results; and from the influence of these on the sentiments and views of the respective proprietors, ensues a division of the society into different interests and parties.
Paragraph 6
[. . .] It is in vain to say that enlightened statesmen will be able to adjust these clashing interests, and render them all subservient to the public good. Enlightened statesmen will not always be at the helm. Nor, in many cases, can such an adjustment be made at all without taking into view indirect and remote considerations, which will rarely prevail over the immediate interest which one party may find in disregarding the rights of another or the good of the whole.
Paragraph 7
The inference to which we are brought is, that the CAUSES of faction cannot be removed, and that relief is only to be sought in the means of controlling its EFFECTS.

James Madison, The Federalist No. 10, first published in New York newspapers in November 1787 under the pen name Publius, as part of a series urging ratification of the Constitution. Madison defines a faction as a group of citizens united by a passion or interest opposed to other citizens’ rights or the community’s interests. The bracketed ellipses mark omitted text. Text from The Federalist Papers, Project Gutenberg eBook #1404.

Question 4 of 4

In paragraphs 2 and 3, Madison divides the possible cures for faction into two methods and then divides one of those methods in two. In the context of the passage as a whole, this organization primarily serves to

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.