AP® English Language and Composition Unit 9 flashcardsCounterarguments: Concession, Rebuttal and Refutation
27 cards · about 7 minutes for the whole deck
Flashcard drill
Space flips the card, arrow keys move, and keys 1 to 4 rate how well you knew it.
- Position
- 1 / 27
- Due
- 27
- Mastered
- 0 / 27
This card: New
Flip the card before you rate it.
Ongoing conversation
The idea that people were debating an issue long before you joined. A strong argument responds to positions others have already taken.
Topic 9.1: Joining an ongoing conversation
Entering the conversation
Opening by summarizing what others have said, then adding your own view: agreeing, disagreeing or agreeing with a difference.
Topic 9.1: Joining an ongoing conversation
Supporting source
A source whose evidence backs your thesis directly. It's your main building material, but it isn't the only kind you need.
Topic 9.1: Joining an ongoing conversation
Complementary source
A source that doesn't argue your point outright but adds context or a related reason, like a health report showing why safer biking would matter.
Topic 9.1: Joining an ongoing conversation
Contradicting source
A source whose evidence cuts against your thesis. Don't hide it: concede, rebut or refute it, or adjust your claim.
Topic 9.1: Joining an ongoing conversation
Agreeing with a difference
Accepting another writer's claim but adding a condition, an extension or a new reason. It lets you join the conversation without just repeating others.
Topic 9.1: Joining an ongoing conversation
Anticipating an objection
Raising an objection before your reader does, often with "Some may object that...." It shows you've thought ahead.
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view
Counterargument
A claim or evidence that opposes your position. Taking it on fairly shows you understand the issue.
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view
Concession
Granting that an opposing point is partly or fully right, or that your own claim has limits. Done well, it makes readers trust you more.
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view
Strongest opposing view
The most convincing form of the other side's argument. Mill says you must know it to truly understand your own position.
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view
Fair summary
Stating an opposing view the way its supporters would. Twisting it instead hurts your credibility.
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view
Partial concession
Granting part of an opposing claim while rejecting the rest, as Madison admits complaints are "in some degree true."
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view
Rebuttal
Answering an opposing claim with a different view or other evidence to show it's at least partly wrong. It challenges a claim without fully disproving it.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Refutation
Using evidence or reasoning to show that all or part of an opposing claim is false. It goes further than rebuttal.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Counterclaim
The specific claim made by the other side. Name it clearly before you respond to it.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Contradictory evidence
Evidence that conflicts with a claim. Use it to refute an opponent, and take it seriously when it conflicts with yours.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Straw man
A distorted, weaker version of an opponent's argument, set up to be easily knocked down. Readers who notice it stop trusting you.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Turning an opponent's premise
Showing that the other side's own starting point supports your conclusion, as Douglass uses slaveholders' laws as proof of enslaved people's humanity.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Reductio ad absurdum
Refuting a claim by showing it leads to an absurd result, as Madison says abolishing liberty to stop faction is like abolishing air to stop fire.
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Concede-and-respond paragraph
A paragraph that states an objection, grants what's fair in it, then rebuts or refutes the rest: "It's true that... but...."
Topic 9.3: Rebutting and refuting
Admittedly / Granted
Transitions that signal you're about to concede a point. They prepare the reader for a "but" that returns to your argument.
Topic 9.4: Transitions into counterarguments, and when to skip them
Some argue that
A signal phrase that introduces an opposing view and makes clear it isn't your own position.
Topic 9.4: Transitions into counterarguments, and when to skip them
Even so / Nevertheless
Transitions that move from a concession back to your argument, signaling that the concession doesn't change your main claim.
Topic 9.4: Transitions into counterarguments, and when to skip them
Imagined objector
An opponent a writer invents to voice the other side, like Mill's "some one may say." It lets the writer answer an objection head-on.
Topic 9.4: Transitions into counterarguments, and when to skip them
When to skip a counterargument
Leave out objections that are trivial or that no reasonable reader holds. Answering weak objections distracts from your line of reasoning.
Topic 9.4: Transitions into counterarguments, and when to skip them
Placing a counterargument
Deal with an objection before your conclusion, often just before it, so your final claim stands on answered objections.
Topic 9.4: Transitions into counterarguments, and when to skip them
Sophistication point
The last essay point. One way to earn it is to explain an issue's complexity, for example by weighing counterarguments and limits.
Topic 9.2: Conceding part of an opposing view