Skip to main content

Unit 2 · Topic 2.6

2.6 Writing a defensible thesis statement

A defensible thesis takes a clear position that someone could argue against and that you can back up with evidence. It answers the prompt directly. Restating the prompt, listing both sides or stating an obvious fact won't earn the thesis point.

Key terms

  • thesis statement
  • defensible
  • position
  • prompt

What "defensible" means

Defensible has two halves. Someone could reasonably disagree with it, so it's worth arguing. And you can support it with evidence: from the sources in the synthesis essay, from the passage in the rhetorical analysis essay, or from your own knowledge in the argument essay.

The thesis row of the rubric, in plain words

All three essays are scored out of 6 on the same three rows. Row A, the thesis row, is worth 1 point. You earn it with a thesis that answers the prompt and takes a position you could defend with evidence. In the rhetorical analysis essay, the thesis has to analyze the writer's choices, not just summarize the passage or state your opinion of the topic.

  • Doesn't earn it: only restating or rephrasing the prompt.
  • Doesn't earn it: not taking a position, or a position so vague a reader has to guess it.
  • Doesn't earn it: summarizing both sides ("some say yes, some say no") without choosing.
  • Doesn't earn it: stating an obvious fact that needs no defense.
  • Doesn't earn it: a thesis that answers a different question from the one asked.
  • Allowed: a thesis of more than one sentence, as long as the sentences are together. It can technically appear anywhere, but end your first paragraph with it so readers can't miss it.

Starter templates

Templates are a starting point, not a cage. Fill them with specific words.

EssayTemplateExample (written for this page)
Synthesis (Q1)[Position], because [reason] and [reason].Cities should replace overdue fines with automatic renewals, because fines keep the poorest families away and bring in little money.
Rhetorical analysis (Q2)[Writer] [does what] in order to [purpose] for [audience].Paine shames the faint-hearted and honors the steadfast to keep discouraged Americans committed to the war.
Argument (Q3)[Position], although/because [limit or reason].Failure teaches more than success, but only when someone helps you study what went wrong.

Making a thesis stronger

  • Be specific: name the real issue, not "society" or "many things."
  • Take a side, even if you add a limit with "although" or "unless."
  • Skip "I think" or "In my opinion"; the essay is your opinion already.
  • In Q2, name what the writer is doing and why, not a list of devices like "ethos, pathos and logos."

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Sorting theses for an argument prompt

    Practice prompt (written for this page): "Some people say that failure teaches us more than success. Write an essay that argues your position on this claim." Decide which of these theses earn Row A, and why. (1) "Failure and success both teach lessons." (2) "Some people say failure teaches more than success." (3) "Everyone fails at some point in life." (4) "Failure teaches more than success, but only when someone is willing to study what went wrong instead of hurrying past it."

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Thesis 1 doesn't choose a side. Saying both teach lessons avoids the question.
    2. Step 2: Thesis 2 restates the prompt. It's the prompt's own words with nothing added.
    3. Step 3: Thesis 3 states an obvious fact. Nobody would argue with it, and it doesn't answer the prompt.
    4. Step 4: Thesis 4 takes a clear position and adds a condition that sets up a line of reasoning. Someone could disagree, and it can be defended with examples.

    Answer: Only thesis 4 earns the point. It takes a defensible position on the prompt's claim and adds a limit ("only when someone is willing to study what went wrong") that makes it more precise.

  2. Example 2

    From device list to real rhetorical analysis thesis

    Using Thomas Paine's opening to "The American Crisis" (see topic 1.2), revise this weak Question 2 thesis: "Paine uses ethos, pathos and logos to persuade his audience."

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Diagnose: the thesis names labels that fit almost any text and says nothing about Paine's purpose or audience.
    2. Step 2: Name the real choices: sorting people into "summer soldiers" and those who stand firm, and framing hardship as what makes victory valuable.
    3. Step 3: Name the purpose and audience: to keep discouraged soldiers and civilians committed in December 1776.
    4. Step 4: Join choices and purpose in one or two sentences.

    Answer: Revised thesis: Writing as the army retreated, Paine shames the "summer soldier" and praises those who stand firm, then recasts the war's hardships as the price that makes freedom valuable, all to keep discouraged Americans from abandoning the cause.

Common mistakes

  • Restating the prompt in slightly different words and calling it a thesis.
  • Writing "There are pros and cons" or "It depends" with no position.
  • Listing devices ("ethos, pathos and logos") in a Question 2 thesis instead of the writer's purpose and specific choices.
  • Answering a nearby question instead of the one the prompt asks.

On the exam

  • Row A is only 1 point, but it's the most reliable point on the essay. Write a clear thesis before you start your body paragraphs.
  • A thesis can preview your line of reasoning, but it doesn't have to. A clear position with a reason is enough to earn the point.

Connected topics

Videos

  • How to Write a Defensible Thesis for AP Lang, AP Lit, and AP History | Coach Hall Writes

    Coach Hall WritesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Ace the AP Lang Argument Essay - Step 3: Write a Thesis

    Marco LearningWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • The ONLY WAY to Make YOUR Argument Thesis COMPLEX!

    Garden of EnglishWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Write a STRONG Thesis Statement | Scribbr 🎓

    ScribbrWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Thesis Statements for AP Lang Q1 & Q3 Synthesis & Argument | Coach Hall Writes

    Coach Hall WritesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Write AMAZING Rhetorical Analysis Thesis Statements!

    Garden of EnglishWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 2.6 Writing a defensible thesis statement

4 questions on 2.6 Writing a defensible thesis statement. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
(1) When our district announced that students would need forty hours of community service to graduate, the complaints in the hallway started within minutes. (2) Across the country, more and more high schools are adding similar requirements, and students everywhere seem to have mixed feelings about them. (3) Some see the hours as a chore to check off, while others discover causes they care about for years. (4) Community service is a requirement at many schools.
Paragraph 2
(5) Required service exposes students to problems they might never otherwise see. (6) When I volunteered at the Eastside Food Pantry for my sophomore hours, I met families who worked full time and still could not afford groceries. (7) One father told me that he held two jobs and still needed the pantry every Thursday. (8) That conversation changed how I think about hunger in my own town.
Paragraph 3
(9) My friends also did service hours. (10) A classmate who spent her hours at an animal shelter now plans to study veterinary medicine. (11) Another friend realized while tutoring fourth graders that he wants to become a teacher. (12) Discoveries like these rarely happen in a classroom, where students study subjects but seldom try out the work itself.
Paragraph 4
(13) A requirement only works if students have real choices. (14) A student assigned to file papers in an office for twenty hours learns little except how to watch the clock. (15) At my school, students may choose from more than sixty approved organizations or propose a project of their own. (16) Schools that let students pick from many kinds of projects, including ones they design themselves, see more students keep volunteering after graduation.
Paragraph 5
(17) Required service, then, is worth keeping, but only if students have a real say in where they serve. (18) Without that choice, forty hours become just another box to check.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of an argument essay answering the question, “Should high schools require community service for graduation?”

Question 1 of 4

In sentence 4 (reproduced below), the writer wants to state a defensible thesis that sets up the essay’s argument. Community service is a requirement at many schools. Which version of sentence 4 best achieves this purpose?

Question 2 of 4

The writer wants to add a word or phrase at the beginning of sentence 13 (adjusting for capitalization as needed) to show that paragraph 4 limits the support for requirements given in paragraphs 2 and 3. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

Question 3 of 4

In sentence 17 (reproduced below), the writer wants to restate the thesis in a way that reflects both parts of the essay’s argument. Required service, then, is worth keeping, but only if students have a real say in where they serve. Which version of sentence 17 best achieves this purpose?

Paragraph 1
(1) For more than a century, the brick train station on Depot Street has stood at the center of Millbrook. (2) Generations of residents have bought tickets at its oak counter, waited on its wooden benches and watched for trains from its long platform. (3) The town council is now deciding whether to tear the station down and build a modern transit center in its place, and it plans to vote at its meeting next month. (4) The old station has been part of Millbrook for a long time.
Paragraph 2
(5) Restoring the station would cost less than many people assume, and the work would be finished sooner. (6) An engineering report prepared for the council last year found the building’s frame and foundation to be sound. (7) Repairs to the roof, wiring and platforms are estimated at $2.1 million, compared with $3.4 million for a new center. (8) The report also found that restoration would take about fourteen months, while tearing down the station and building a new center would take nearly three years.
Paragraph 3
(9) The station also gives Millbrook a sense of who it is. (10) My grandmother still talks about waving goodbye to her brother from its platform in 1951, when he left for the Army. (11) Like a family photo album, an old building holds memories that a new one cannot. (12) The station’s clock tower was added in 1925 and, after a few repairs, still keeps good time.
Paragraph 4
(13) A restored station could offer the same benches, ticket machines and bike racks that a new center would, along with screens showing when the next train will arrive. (14) It could also add an elevator to the platform, which the current building lacks. (15) Trains could keep running during the work, since the platforms could be repaired one at a time. (16) Millbrook can have modern service without erasing its past.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of an argument for the town newspaper. Millbrook and its report are invented.

Question 4 of 4

In sentence 4 (reproduced below), the writer wants to state a position that the rest of the passage will defend and preview the reasons for it. The old station has been part of Millbrook for a long time. Which version of sentence 4 best achieves this purpose?

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.