Skip to main content

Unit 3 · Topic 3.1

3.1 Commentary: explaining how evidence supports a claim

Commentary is your explanation of how and why a piece of evidence supports your claim and moves your argument forward. It's the difference between a summary and an argument, and it's what Row B of the essay rubric, Evidence and Commentary, worth 4 of the 6 points, rewards most.

Key terms

  • commentary
  • analysis
  • evidence
  • claim

What commentary does

Evidence shows readers something. Commentary tells them what it means. Good commentary does three jobs: it makes the logical link between the evidence and your claim, it explains why the evidence matters, and it shows how this point fits into your larger line of reasoning.

If you deleted your commentary and your paragraph still said the same thing, you didn't have commentary, only a summary with quotation marks.

Summary versus commentary

Summary says...Commentary says...
Paine says tyranny is hard to beat.Paine compares tyranny to hell, which turns a political fight into a moral one.
Thoreau lists the cost of his house.Thoreau's half-cent precision makes him sound like a careful accountant, not a dreamer, so readers trust his claim that simple living is affordable.
Source C shows that families in low-income neighborhoods owe the most in fines.Source C's data suggests fines fall hardest on the families with the least money, which undercuts the idea that fines are a fair penalty.

Questions that produce commentary

  • What does this word, image or detail suggest beyond its literal meaning?
  • Why would this audience, at this moment, respond to it?
  • What would be lost if the writer had said it a plainer way?
  • How does this connect to my claim, and to my thesis?
  • So what? Why does this matter for the writer's purpose?

Moves and verbs for commentary

Sentence frames help when you're stuck: "By ___, [the writer] ___, which ___." "This choice matters because ___." "For an audience that ___, this ___."

Precise verbs make commentary sharper than "shows." Try: suggests, implies, reinforces, undercuts, dignifies, mocks, reframes, heightens, invites, contrasts, unites, warns, concedes, challenges.

Another useful move is "not just... but": "The image doesn't just describe the hallway; it makes readers feel trapped in it." It pushes you past the obvious meaning toward the effect.

Row B in plain words

Row B is worth 0 to 4 points. Low scores come from restating the thesis, repeating information, or summarizing evidence without explaining it. A middle score explains some evidence but without a clear line of reasoning. The top score supplies specific evidence for every claim and consistently explains how that evidence supports a line of reasoning. In the synthesis essay, the evidence also has to come from at least three of the provided sources to score above 1. Consistently is the key word: commentary belongs in every paragraph, not just one.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    From summary to commentary

    Write a Question 2 body paragraph on this sentence from Thomas Paine's first "American Crisis" (December 1776), written to keep discouraged Americans in the war: "Tyranny, like hell, is not easily conquered; yet we have this consolation with us, that the harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph." First look at a summary-only draft (written for this page): "Paine says that tyranny is like hell and hard to conquer. He says the harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph. This shows he wants people to keep fighting."

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Diagnose the draft: it repeats Paine's words, then adds a vague "this shows" sentence. That's Row B's low end.
    2. Step 2: Find what's worth explaining: the simile "like hell" and the turn at "yet," which flips the hardship into a reason for hope.
    3. Step 3: Ask why it would work on this audience: soldiers were exhausted and losing. Paine can't deny that it's hard, so he redefines the hardship.
    4. Step 4: Write claim, evidence, commentary, and a link to the purpose. Let the commentary be longer than the quotations.

    Answer: Model paragraph: [Claim] Paine admits the war is brutal, then turns that admission into a reason to keep going. [Evidence] He compares tyranny to hell, "not easily conquered," [Commentary] a simile that raises the stakes from a quarrel over taxes to a struggle against something evil, so giving up would mean surrendering to it. [Evidence] Then he pivots on "yet": "the harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph." [Commentary] For soldiers who had just lost battle after battle, this is a clever move. Paine doesn't pretend things are going well, which would sound false; instead he makes their suffering the very thing that will give victory its value. [Link] The worse the winter gets, the more each soldier who stays becomes part of a story worth telling, which is exactly the commitment Paine needs.

Common mistakes

  • Writing "This shows that..." and then repeating the quotation in other words.
  • Saving all the commentary for the last sentence of a paragraph instead of explaining each piece of evidence as it appears.
  • Naming a device ("Paine uses a simile") as if naming it were the analysis.
  • Using long quotations with one short sentence of explanation. Aim for at least as much commentary as quotation.

On the exam

  • Row B is worth 4 of the 6 points on every essay, so most of your time should go into evidence and commentary.
  • Reading questions about the function of a sentence or detail are testing the same skill: explaining what a piece of text does for the argument.

Connected topics

Videos

  • What is Commentary? | AP Lang FAQ | Coach Hall Writes

    Coach Hall WritesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Commentary was Hard Until I Learned THIS!

    Garden of EnglishWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • AP English Language: Rubric Walkthrough for Q2: Rhetorical Analysis

    Marco LearningWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Write the BEST Argument Commentary!

    Garden of EnglishWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Improve Your Rhetorical Analysis Commentary | AP Lang Q2 | Coach Hall Writes

    Coach Hall WritesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 3.1 Commentary: explaining how evidence supports a claim

4 questions on 3.1 Commentary: explaining how evidence supports a claim. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
(1) In March 1865, with the Civil War nearly won, Abraham Lincoln stood before a crowd outside the Capitol to begin his second term. (2) Four years of fighting had killed hundreds of thousands of soldiers, and many in the North wanted the South to pay. (3) Many listeners expected him to celebrate the Union’s coming victory. (4) Instead, he gave a speech of about seven hundred words that never once boasts. (5) Lincoln uses many rhetorical devices in his second inaugural address.
Paragraph 2
(6) Lincoln begins by playing down his own role. (7) He tells the crowd that “little that is new could be presented” and that, about the future, “no prediction in regard to it is ventured.” (8) This quotation is from the first paragraph of the speech. (9) A boastful speech near the end of the war would have deepened the anger between North and South that he hoped to calm.
Paragraph 3
(10) Lincoln turns next to the cause of the war. (11) He states plainly that slavery “was somehow the cause of the war,” yet he does not let the North feel righteous. (12) He reminds his listeners that both sides “read the same Bible and pray to the same God.” (13) This shows that Lincoln uses religion. (14) The Union, Lincoln implies, cannot claim that God was on its side alone.
Paragraph 4
(15) Lincoln closes with the sentence that is now carved on the wall of the Lincoln Memorial. (16) He urges the nation to act “with malice toward none, with charity for all” and “to bind up the nation’s wounds.” (17) The Gettysburg Address, which Lincoln delivered in 1863, is even shorter than this speech. (18) Because he has already set aside both boasting and blame, this call for mercy sounds like the natural end of his reasoning rather than a sudden request.
Paragraph 5
(19) Six weeks later, Lincoln was assassinated, and the address became his farewell to the nation. (20) Instead of treating the end of the war as a triumph over enemies, he treated it as a shared tragedy that both sides would have to repair together. (21) Its lesson remains: a leader who wants to heal a divided country must first refuse to gloat.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of a rhetorical analysis essay on Abraham Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address, delivered March 4, 1865. The quotations from Lincoln’s speech are accurate.

Question 1 of 4

In sentence 8 (reproduced below), the writer wants to explain how the evidence in sentence 7 supports the claim in sentence 6. This quotation is from the first paragraph of the speech. Which version of sentence 8 best achieves this purpose?

Question 2 of 4

In sentence 13 (reproduced below), the writer wants to explain how Lincoln’s reference to a shared faith affects his audience. This shows that Lincoln uses religion. Which version of sentence 13 best achieves this purpose?

Paragraph 1
(1) Every summer, Westfield asks residents to water their lawns only on certain days of the week. (2) Yet every spring, many of us plant the same thirsty grass again. (3) This year the town council is considering a program that would pay homeowners up to $500 to replace part of their lawns with native plants. (4) Lawns are a familiar part of life in Westfield.
Paragraph 2
(5) The strongest reason to support the program is water. (6) According to the Westfield Water Department, watering lawns accounts for about 40 percent of the town’s household water use in summer (Source A). (7) Native plants, which are adapted to local rainfall, usually need little watering once they are established (Source B). (8) That is a lot of water. (9) Last July, the town had to ban lawn watering entirely for two weeks when the reservoir fell below its safe level (Source A).
Paragraph 3
(10) Some residents worry about appearance. (11) In a letter to the council, the Maple Ridge Homeowners’ Association warns that native gardens “look unkempt” and could lower property values (Source C). (12) Ana Brooks, a landscape designer who has planned native gardens for dozens of local homes, disagrees. (13) She argues that a native garden “can look as tidy as any lawn if it is planned with clear edges and paths” (Source B). (14) She points to the town library, whose native garden of coneflowers and switchgrass is bordered by a low stone wall and drew praise from the county garden club (Source B). (15) The association and the magazine article see the issue differently.
Paragraph 4
(16) The program would have a cost. (17) If two hundred households joined, the town would pay out as much as $100,000. (18) That is real money for a town of twelve thousand people. (19) Westfield cannot make it rain, but it can stop pouring so much of its water onto grass. (20) Native gardens will not solve every water problem, but they are a step residents can take one yard at a time. (21) The council should approve the program this spring.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of a synthesis essay on whether Westfield should pay homeowners to replace lawns with native plants. Source A is a town water report, Source B is a magazine article and Source C is a letter from a homeowners’ association; the town, the people named and all three sources are invented.

Question 3 of 4

In sentence 8 (reproduced below), the writer wants to explain how the evidence in sentences 6 and 7 supports the claim in sentence 5. That is a lot of water. Which version of sentence 8 best achieves this purpose?

Question 4 of 4

In sentence 15 (reproduced below), the writer wants to put Sources B and C in conversation in a way that advances the writer’s own argument. The association and the magazine article see the issue differently. Which version of sentence 15 best achieves this purpose?

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.