Skip to main content

Unit 1 · Topic 1.6

1.6 Writing a claim-and-evidence paragraph

A claim-and-evidence paragraph states a claim, brings in evidence by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing, and explains how the evidence supports the claim. Working evidence smoothly into your own sentences shows readers you're in control of your sources.

Key terms

  • topic sentence
  • quotation
  • paraphrase
  • summary
  • commentary

The basic shape

Most strong paragraphs follow the same path. First, a topic sentence states the paragraph's claim. Next comes evidence that supports it. Then you explain how that evidence proves the claim, which is called commentary. Often a last sentence links back to your thesis. You can repeat the evidence-and-commentary pair more than once in a paragraph.

Quote, paraphrase or summarize

There are three ways to bring a source into your writing. The examples below use Ralph Waldo Emerson's essay "Self-Reliance" (1841).

MethodUse it whenExample
QuoteThe exact words matterEmerson insists that "Whoso would be a man, must be a nonconformist."
ParaphraseYou need the idea, not the wordingEmerson argues that becoming a full person means refusing to simply follow the crowd.
SummarizeYou need the big picture of a longer passageIn "Self-Reliance," Emerson urges readers to trust their own judgment over custom and public opinion.

Embedding evidence in your own sentences

A "dropped quote" is a quotation that sits alone as its own sentence, with no lead-in. It forces readers to guess why it's there. Instead, bring the quotation in with a signal phrase ("Emerson warns that...") or blend a short piece of it into your own grammar.

Short quotations usually work better than long ones. Quote only the words you plan to discuss. If you cut words out of the middle, use an ellipsis (...); if you change a word to fit your sentence, put your change in square brackets. Never trim a quotation so that it says something the writer didn't mean.

  • Signal phrase: As Emerson puts it, "..."
  • Blended: Emerson calls a thoughtless habit of agreeing with yourself "the hobgoblin of little minds."
  • Colon after a full sentence: Emerson's warning is blunt: "..."

Then explain

Evidence never explains itself. After every piece of evidence, write at least a sentence that tells the reader how it supports your claim. Topic 3.1 covers this explaining, called commentary, in depth.

A helpful rule is to sandwich every piece of evidence: introduce it, present it, then explain it. If a paragraph has two pieces of evidence, it needs commentary after each one, not a single sentence of explanation at the very end. Readers can tell the difference between a paragraph that argues and one that collects quotations.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Fixing a dropped quote

    Practice draft (written for this page), answering the prompt "Is it better to fit in or to stand out?": "It is better to stand out. 'A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.' People should be themselves." Revise it into a full claim-and-evidence paragraph using Emerson's line from "Self-Reliance" (1841).

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Diagnose: the claim is vague, the quotation is dropped in with no lead-in, and nothing explains how it connects to the claim.
    2. Step 2: Sharpen the claim so it says why standing out matters.
    3. Step 3: Introduce the source and the quotation with a signal phrase so readers know who is speaking.
    4. Step 4: Explain what the quotation means and how it supports the claim.
    5. Step 5: Link back to the larger argument.

    Answer: Model paragraph: [Claim] Standing out is worth the discomfort, because people who always go along with the group lose the habit of thinking for themselves. [Evidence] Emerson makes this point in "Self-Reliance," warning that "a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." [Commentary] By calling mindless consistency a "hobgoblin," a small nagging spirit, Emerson suggests that the urge to stick with whatever you said before haunts and shrinks the mind instead of guiding it. In the same essay he pairs that fear with conformity, the fear of disagreeing with everyone else, as the two habits that keep people from trusting themselves. [Link] A student who changes an opinion after hearing a better argument may look inconsistent, but that student is doing the independent thinking that fitting in discourages.

Common mistakes

  • Dropping a quotation in as its own sentence with no introduction.
  • Quoting a long passage when only a few words matter. Quote the key words and explain them.
  • Ending a paragraph on a quotation, which leaves the reader to make the argument for you.
  • Cutting a quotation so it misrepresents the writer's meaning.

On the exam

  • Writing questions on the exam often ask which version best integrates a quotation or which sentence best follows a piece of evidence. Pick the one that connects the evidence to the claim.
  • In Question 2, embed short quotations from the passage directly into your sentences. Readers look for specific evidence followed by your explanation.

Connected topics

Videos

  • How to integrate quotes into an essay: I.C.E. Method | Coach Hall Writes

    Coach Hall WritesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Explain and Elaborate on a Claim and Evidence in a Paragraph

    Mister MessingerWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • The ONLY Way to Include Evidence in an Argument Essay!

    Garden of EnglishWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Quoting, Paraphrasing and Summarizing

    BYU MCOMWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Write Strong Essay Body Paragraphs – with REAL Example | Scribbr 🎓

    ScribbrWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 1.6 Writing a claim-and-evidence paragraph

5 questions on 1.6 Writing a claim-and-evidence paragraph. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
(1) At 3:30 every afternoon, the lights in the Westbrook High library go off, and a librarian politely asks the last few students to pack up. (2) For many of us, that is exactly when we need the library most. (3) The library has twenty-four computers and a quiet study room. (4) The school should keep the library open until 6:00 p.m. on weekdays.
Paragraph 2
(5) Not every student has a quiet place to study at home, and many have no computer of their own. (6) In a survey of 312 Westbrook students that our newspaper staff conducted in September, 41 percent said they share a bedroom, and 28 percent said they do not have reliable internet at home. (7) For these students, homework that requires a computer often has to wait until the next morning’s study hall. (8) Students who stay after school for sports or clubs face a different problem. (9) By the time practice ends at 5:00, the library has been closed for an hour and a half. (10) Last spring, junior Dev Patel wrote most of his history research paper on his phone because the library closed before his practice ended. (11) “I typed eleven pages with my thumbs,” he told me.
Paragraph 3
(12) Some readers will point out that keeping the library open would cost money, since a staff member would have to supervise. (13) That concern is fair. (14) However, the district already pays for an after-school bus at 5:45, so students who stay late would have a ride home. (15) Two other high schools in our district, Northview and Eastfield, already keep their libraries open until 6:00.
Paragraph 4
(16) The library is one of the best resources Westbrook has, and right now it sits dark during the hours when students could use it most. (17) If Northview and Eastfield can find a way, so can we.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of an opinion column for the school newspaper.

Question 1 of 5

The writer wants to add a sentence after sentence 6 that explains how the survey results support the claim in sentence 5. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

Paragraph 1
(1) On a July afternoon in Milford, the sidewalk outside my apartment on Grant Street can get hot enough to burn a dog’s paws. (2) Three blocks away, on tree-lined Elm Avenue, people sit on their front steps and talk with their neighbors. (3) The difference between the two streets is not luck; it is shade. (4) Milford should plant trees on its hottest blocks first.
Paragraph 2
(5) Shade does more than make a street look pleasant. (6) The Milford Heat Map Project, a volunteer group that measured temperatures across the city last summer, found that afternoon air on blocks with few trees was as much as 8 degrees hotter than on shaded blocks. (7) “The pattern was the same in every neighborhood we measured,” said project leader Dr. Lena Ruiz, an urban forester. (8) Those degrees matter, because heat can be dangerous for older adults and young children. (9) Grant Street, where many retired people and young families live, has fewer than a dozen street trees along its entire length.
Paragraph 3
(10) Planting the hottest blocks first is also the fairest way to spend the city’s tree budget. (11) Under the current plan, the city plants new trees wherever residents request them. (12) Residents who have time to fill out forms and attend meetings get trees, while neighborhoods where people work long hours keep waiting. (13) The Heat Map Project found that the blocks with the fewest trees are also the blocks that have sent in the fewest requests.
Paragraph 4
(14) Some residents argue that trees are expensive to maintain. (15) Trees do need watering and pruning. (16) But the city already spends money every summer running cooling centers for people whose homes get too hot. (17) According to the parks department’s budget, staffing a single cooling center costs about $9,000 a summer.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of an argument for a civics class. Milford and its sources are invented.

Question 2 of 5

The writer is considering deleting sentence 3 (reproduced below). The difference between the two streets is not luck; it is shade. Should the writer keep or delete this sentence?

Question 3 of 5

The writer wants to add a sentence after sentence 7 that explains how the Heat Map Project’s findings support the claim in sentence 4. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

Question 4 of 5

The writer wants to add a word or phrase at the beginning of sentence 12 (adjusting for capitalization as needed) to show that it describes a result of the policy in sentence 11. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

Question 5 of 5

The writer wants to combine sentences 15 and 16 (reproduced below) so that the new sentence admits the cost of trees but makes her own point clear. Trees do need watering and pruning. But the city already spends money every summer running cooling centers for people whose homes get too hot. Which version best achieves this purpose?

0 of 5 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.