Skip to main content

Unit 9 · Topic 9.3

9.3 Rebutting and refuting

To rebut is to answer an opposing claim with a different way of looking at it, or with other evidence, to suggest that it's at least partly wrong. To refute goes further: you use evidence to show that all or part of the opposing claim doesn't hold up. Both make your argument more credible than ignoring the other side.

Key terms

  • rebuttal
  • refutation
  • counterclaim
  • contradictory evidence
  • invalid

Concede, rebut, refute

These three responses to an opposing argument often work together, but they do different jobs:

MoveWhat you doSignal phrases
ConcedeGrant that part of the opposing view is right, or right in some circumstancesAdmittedly, Granted, It's true that
RebutOffer a contrasting perspective or alternative evidence suggesting the opposing claim is wrong, at least in partHowever, But this overlooks, A better way to see it
RefuteShow with evidence that all or part of the opposing claim is invalidThe evidence shows otherwise, In fact, This claim fails because

Ways to rebut

  • Reframe it: show the same facts mean something different (as Paine does with British "protection" in 9.2).
  • Weigh it: admit the point but argue that other factors matter more.
  • Find a flaw in the reasoning: show that the opposing claim depends on a hasty generalization, a false cause or a faulty comparison (3.5).
  • Offer alternative evidence: present examples or data that point the other way.

Refuting with evidence

A refutation is stronger than a rebuttal because it doesn't just offer another view; it demonstrates that the opposing claim is false. That takes specific evidence: a statistic that contradicts the claim, a counterexample that breaks a generalization, or a fact the opposing argument depends on that turns out to be wrong.

On the synthesis essay, refutation often means setting one source against another: if Source C claims a program failed, but Source E's data show results improved once the program was fully running, you can use E to refute part of C. Explain why E's evidence deserves more weight, for example because it covers more time or more people.

Refuting a claim completely is hard, so writers often refute part of it: "The claim that the program costs too much rests on the first year's numbers; by the third year, the city spent less than before." Be honest about how much you've disproved.

Rebutting fairly

Respond to the opposing argument at its strongest. Rebutting a weak version that no serious person holds is a straw man, and careful readers will notice. Also, attack the claim and the evidence, not the people. Calling opponents foolish or selfish costs you credibility (8.2); showing exactly where their reasoning fails builds it.

In writing questions, you may be asked which sentence would best respond to a counterargument a draft has raised. The best choice answers that specific objection with relevant evidence or reasoning, not with a new, unrelated point.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Paine rebuts, then moves toward refutation

    Thomas Paine, Common Sense (1776; public domain, text from Project Gutenberg): "I have heard it asserted by some, that as America hath flourished under her former connexion with Great-Britain, that the same connexion is necessary towards her future happiness, and will always have the same effect. Nothing can be more fallacious than this kind of argument. We may as well assert that because a child has thrived upon milk, that it is never to have meat, or that the first twenty years of our lives is to become a precedent for the next twenty. But even this is admitting more than is true, for I answer roundly, that America would have flourished as much, and probably much more, had no European power had any thing to do with her. The commerce, by which she hath enriched herself are the necessaries of life, and will always have a market while eating is the custom of Europe." (Fallacious means based on bad reasoning; precedent means a rule set by an earlier case.) Identify Paine's rebuttal and his attempt at refutation.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: State the opposing claim: America prospered under Britain, so it needs Britain to keep prospering.
    2. Step 2: Find the rebuttal: Paine attacks the reasoning with an analogy. A child who thrived on milk still needs meat later; past conditions don't decide future needs. This reframes dependence as a stage to outgrow.
    3. Step 3: Notice the turn: "But even this is admitting more than is true." His analogy granted that Britain helped America grow; now he takes that back.
    4. Step 4: Find the refutation attempt: he claims America would have flourished anyway, and gives a reason: its exports are "necessaries of life," which Europe will always buy.
    5. Step 5: Evaluate: the analogy rebuts by exposing faulty reasoning; the trade argument tries to disprove the claim's premise with evidence about what America sells. It's an asserted reason rather than hard proof, so it counts as an attempted refutation: it works only if readers accept his claim about trade.

    Answer: Paine first rebuts the opposing claim by exposing its faulty reasoning: the milk-and-meat analogy shows that past prosperity under one arrangement doesn't mean the arrangement will always be needed. He then goes further, saying "even this is admitting more than is true," and tries to refute the claim's premise outright: America would have prospered without Britain because the food it sells "will always have a market while eating is the custom of Europe." The two steps work together, first loosening readers' belief that dependence is necessary, then offering a reason to think it was never necessary at all.

Common mistakes

  • Calling any disagreement a "refutation." A refutation shows with evidence that the claim is wrong; offering a different view is a rebuttal.
  • Rebutting a straw man instead of the strongest version of the opposing argument.
  • Attacking the people who hold a view instead of their reasoning and evidence.
  • Raising a counterargument and then never answering it.

On the exam

  • In your essays, one well-developed counterargument, conceded where fair and then rebutted or refuted with specific evidence, does more than several objections mentioned in passing.
  • Reading questions may ask how a writer responds to an opposing view. Decide whether the writer grants it, offers another way to see it, or disproves it with evidence.

Connected topics

Videos

  • How to Write a Counterargument & Rebuttal

    Ms. Peer EditorWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Discover How to Write a Counterclaim Paragraph & Defend with Rebuttal

    Mister MessingerWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Counterargument and Refutation | Argumentative Essay | English Writing Skills

    Worldwide SpeakWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Argumentative Writing: Master Claim, Counterclaim, and Rebuttal for Essays and Debates

    The ELA ConnectionWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Writing the Counterargument and Rebuttal

    Ashley Clark (Ms. Clark's Classroom)Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 9.3 Rebutting and refuting

4 questions on 9.3 Rebutting and refuting. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
I would say to them: You consider yourselves a reasonable and a just people; and I consider that in the general qualities of reason and justice you are not inferior to any other people. Still, when you speak of us Republicans, you do so only to denounce us as reptiles, or, at the best, as no better than outlaws. You will grant a hearing to pirates or murderers, but nothing like it to “Black Republicans.” In all your contentions with one another, each of you deems an unconditional condemnation of “Black Republicanism” as the first thing to be attended to. Indeed, such condemnation of us seems to be an indispensable prerequisite—license, so to speak—among you to be admitted or permitted to speak at all. Now, can you or not be prevailed upon to pause and to consider whether this is quite just to us, or even to yourselves? Bring forward your charges and specifications, and then be patient long enough to hear us deny or justify.
Paragraph 2
You say we are sectional. We deny it. That makes an issue; and the burden of proof is upon you. You produce your proof; and what is it? Why, that our party has no existence in your section—gets no votes in your section. The fact is substantially true; but does it prove the issue? If it does, then, in case we should, without change of principle, begin to get votes in your section, we should thereby cease to be sectional. You cannot escape this conclusion; and yet, are you willing to abide by it? If you are, you will probably soon find that we have ceased to be sectional, for we shall get votes in your section this very year. You will then begin to discover, as the truth plainly is, that your proof does not touch the issue. The fact that we get no votes in your section is a fact of your making, and not of ours.
Paragraph 3
And if there be fault in that fact, that fault is primarily yours, and remains so until you show that we repel you by some wrong principle or practice. If we do repel you by any wrong principle or practice, the fault is ours; but this brings you to where you ought to have started—to a discussion of the right or wrong of our principle. If our principle, put in practice, would wrong your section for the benefit of ours, or for any other object, then our principle, and we with it, are sectional, and are justly opposed and denounced as such. Meet us, then, on the question of whether our principle, put in practice, would wrong your section; and so meet us as if it were possible that something may be said on our side. Do you accept the challenge? No! Then you really believe that the principle which “our fathers who framed the government under which we live” thought so clearly right as to adopt it, and indorse it again and again, upon their official oaths, is in fact so clearly wrong as to demand your condemnation without a moment’s consideration.
Paragraph 4
Some of you delight to flaunt in our faces the warning against sectional parties given by Washington in his Farewell Address. Less than eight years before Washington gave that warning he had, as President of the United States, approved and signed an act of Congress enforcing the prohibition of slavery in the Northwestern Territory, which act embodied the policy of the government upon that subject up to and at the very moment he penned that warning; and about one year after he penned it, he wrote Lafayette that he considered that prohibition a wise measure, expressing in the same connection his hope that we should at some time have a confederacy of free States.
Paragraph 5
Bearing this in mind, and seeing that sectionalism has since arisen upon this same subject, is that warning a weapon in your hands against us, or in our hands against you? Could Washington himself speak, would he cast the blame of that sectionalism upon us, who sustain his policy, or upon you, who repudiate it? We respect that warning of Washington, and we commend it to you, together with his example pointing to the right application of it.
Paragraph 6
[. . .] Again, you say we have made the slavery question more prominent than it formerly was. We deny it. We admit that it is more prominent, but we deny that we made it so. It was not we, but you, who discarded the old policy of the fathers. We resisted, and still resist, your innovation; and thence comes the greater prominence of the question. Would you have that question reduced to its former proportions? Go back to that old policy. What has been will be again, under the same conditions. If you would have the peace of the old times, readopt the precepts and policy of the old times.

Abraham Lincoln, from an address delivered at the Cooper Institute (now Cooper Union) in New York City on February 27, 1860. Lincoln, an Illinois lawyer and a leader of the new Republican Party, which opposed the spread of slavery into the western territories, was seeking the party’s nomination for president. Many Southerners denounced the party as “sectional,” meaning that it served only the North, and called its members “Black Republicans” as an insult. Near the end of the speech, Lincoln turned to address “a few words to the Southern people,” though, as he said, he supposed they would not listen. The Northwestern Territory was the region north of the Ohio River, where a 1787 law banned slavery. The bracketed ellipsis marks omitted text. Text from Speeches & Letters of Abraham Lincoln, 1832–1865 (1907), Project Gutenberg eBook #14721.

Question 1 of 4

In paragraph 2, Lincoln answers the charge that Republicans are “sectional” chiefly by

Question 2 of 4

The reasoning in paragraph 2 that begins “If it does, then, in case we should, without change of principle, begin to get votes in your section” primarily serves to

Question 3 of 4

In paragraph 3, Lincoln writes, “If we do repel you by any wrong principle or practice, the fault is ours.” This concession primarily serves to

Question 4 of 4

In paragraph 3, Lincoln asks, “Do you accept the challenge?” and answers, “No!” This exchange primarily serves to

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.