Skip to main content

Unit 8 · Topic 8.1

8.1 Comparisons that connect with an audience

Writers use similes, metaphors, analogies and anecdotes to link a new or difficult idea to something the audience already knows. A comparison only works if the audience shares the knowledge it depends on. Analyzing a comparison means explaining what it carries over from the familiar thing, and why it suits this audience.

Key terms

  • simile
  • metaphor
  • analogy
  • anecdote
  • audience

Four kinds of comparison

ComparisonWhat it isExample
SimileA comparison using like or asRumors spread like a grease fire.
MetaphorA comparison that says one thing is anotherThe tax code is a maze.
AnalogyAn extended comparison that reasons from a familiar case to an unfamiliar oneSkipping sleep before a test is like draining a car's gas tank before a road trip.
AnecdoteA short story used to illustrate a pointA brief account of one family's struggle to pay a medical bill

Why comparisons persuade

A comparison borrows the audience's existing feelings and understanding. If readers already know that a house needs a solid foundation, calling a policy "the foundation of the economy" asks them to feel that the policy is basic and necessary. The comparison does argumentative work, often without the reader noticing.

Anecdotes work by making a large issue human-sized. Statistics tell readers how many people are affected; an anecdote shows what it's like to be one of them. That's why writers often pair the two.

The audience has to share it

A comparison fails if the audience doesn't know the familiar side. An analogy to a 1950s radio show might confuse a teenage audience; a comparison to a video game might confuse a retirement-home audience. Effective writers choose comparisons from their audience's world: their religion, history, jobs, sports or daily routines.

Comparisons can also fail if they carry the wrong feelings. Comparing a school dress code to "a prison uniform" may energize students but offend the parents and administrators the writer needs to persuade.

In 1776, Thomas Paine answered the claim that America needed Britain because it had prospered under British rule. That reasoning, he wrote, is like saying "because a child has thrived upon milk, that it is never to have meat." Every reader knew children outgrow milk, so the analogy made independence seem like natural growth (9.3).

Analyzing a comparison

  • Name both sides: what is compared to what?
  • Say what carries over: which qualities or feelings move from the familiar thing to the subject?
  • Explain the audience link: why would this audience know and respond to the familiar side?
  • Connect to purpose: how does the comparison move readers toward the writer's goal?

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Lincoln's house divided

    In June 1858, Abraham Lincoln accepted the Illinois Republican Party's nomination for the U.S. Senate. His audience was Republican delegates who opposed the spread of slavery, at a time when many Americans hoped the country could go on half slave and half free indefinitely. He said (public domain; text from Speeches & Letters of Abraham Lincoln, 1832-1865): "In my opinion it will not cease until a crisis shall have been reached and passed. 'A house divided against itself cannot stand.' I believe this government cannot endure permanently, half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved,—I do not expect the house to fall; but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing, or all the other." ("It" in the first sentence refers to the agitation over slavery.) Explain how Lincoln's comparison serves his purpose with this audience.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Identify the comparison: the nation is a house; the slave states and free states are a division inside it.
    2. Step 2: Note the source: "A house divided against itself cannot stand" echoes a saying of Jesus in the Gospels, one Lincoln's Bible-reading audience would recognize at once.
    3. Step 3: Explain what carries over: a house can't stay standing if its parts work against each other. Transferred to the nation, the idea makes the current split seem unstable, not a permanent compromise.
    4. Step 4: Notice how he extends it: "I do not expect the house to fall; but I do expect it will cease to be divided." He keeps the metaphor going to predict an outcome that is less frightening than collapse.
    5. Step 5: Tie to purpose: Lincoln wants his listeners to see that the nation can't stay half slave and half free, so they must commit to stopping slavery's spread.

    Answer: Model paragraph: Lincoln compares the nation to a house to persuade his listeners that the split between slave and free states cannot last. By quoting a biblical saying his audience would know by heart, "A house divided against itself cannot stand," he borrows scriptural authority for a political prediction. Everyone knows that a house whose parts pull against each other is unsafe, so the metaphor turns the country's division from a workable compromise into a structural danger. Lincoln then extends the image to calm his listeners: he does "not expect the house to fall," only that it "will cease to be divided." The familiar picture lets him warn of a crisis without predicting the Union's destruction, pressing his listeners to decide which "one thing" the nation will become.

Common mistakes

  • Identifying a comparison ("he uses a metaphor") without explaining what qualities carry over or why they matter.
  • Ignoring the audience. A comparison's effect depends on what this particular audience knows and values.
  • Confusing an analogy, which reasons from one case to another, with a quick simile or metaphor.

On the exam

  • Reading questions often ask what a comparison suggests or why a writer includes an anecdote. The answer usually links the familiar thing's qualities to the writer's claim.
  • In writing questions, if a draft needs an example or comparison for a specific audience, pick the one drawn from that audience's experience.

Connected topics

Videos

  • Analogy: Explanation, Effects, Example | AP Lang Rhetorical Strategies

    Ms. Peer EditorWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • How to Use Examples, Analogies, Similes and Metaphors when Writing your Essay

    Mister MessingerWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • The art of the metaphor - Jane Hirshfield

    TED-EdWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Anecdotes: Explanation, Effects, Example | AP Lang Rhetorical Strategies

    Ms. Peer EditorWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Arguments from analogy

    Philosophy ClassroomWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 8.1 Comparisons that connect with an audience

4 questions on 8.1 Comparisons that connect with an audience. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
An ancient Sage boasted, that, tho' he could not fiddle, he knew how to make a great city of a little one. The science that I, a modern simpleton, am about to communicate, is the very reverse.
Paragraph 2
I address myself to all ministers who have the management of extensive dominions, which from their very greatness are become troublesome to govern, because the multiplicity of their affairs leaves no time for fiddling.
Paragraph 3
I. In the first place, gentlemen, you are to consider, that a great empire, like a great cake, is most easily diminished at the edges. Turn your attention, therefore, first to your remotest provinces; that, as you get rid of them, the next may follow in order.
Paragraph 4
II. That the possibility of this separation may always exist, take special care the provinces are never incorporated with the mother country; that they do not enjoy the same common rights, the same privileges in commerce; and that they are governed by severer laws, all of your enacting, without allowing them any share in the choice of the legislators. By carefully making and preserving such distinctions, you will (to keep to my simile of the cake) act like a wise ginger-bread-baker, who, to facilitate a division, cuts his dough half through in those places where, when baked, he would have it broken to pieces.
Paragraph 5
[. . .] IV. However peaceably your colonies have submitted to your government, shewn their affection to your interests, and patiently borne their grievances; you are to suppose them always inclined to revolt, and treat them accordingly. Quarter troops among them, who by their insolence may provoke the rising of mobs, and by their bullets and bayonets suppress them. By this means, like the husband who uses his wife ill from suspicion, you may in time convert your suspicions into realities.
Paragraph 6
[. . .] VI. To confirm these impressions, and strike them deeper, whenever the injured come to the capital with complaints of maladministration, oppression, or injustice, punish such suitors with long delay, enormous expence, and a final judgment in favour of the oppressor. This will have an admirable effect every way. The trouble of future complaints will be prevented, and Governors and Judges will be encouraged to farther acts of oppression and injustice; and thence the people may become more disaffected, and at length desperate.
Paragraph 7
[. . .] VIII. If, when you are engaged in war, your colonies should vie in liberal aids of men and money against the common enemy, upon your simple requisition, and give far beyond their abilities, reflect that a penny taken from them by your power is more honourable to you, than a pound presented by their benevolence; despise therefore their voluntary grants; and resolve to harass them with novel taxes. They will probably complain to your parliaments, that they are taxed by a body in which they have no representative, and that this is contrary to common right. They will petition for redress. Let the Parliaments flout their claims, reject their petitions, refuse even to suffer the reading of them, and treat the petitioners with the utmost contempt. Nothing can have a better effect in producing the alienation proposed; for though many can forgive injuries, none ever forgave contempt.

Benjamin Franklin, "Rules by Which a Great Empire May Be Reduced to a Small One" (1773). Franklin, then living in London as an agent for several American colonies, published this satire in a London newspaper, the Public Advertiser, in September 1773, and it was reprinted that month in the Gentleman's Magazine. Its subtitle reads "Presented to a late Minister, when he entered upon his Administration." The "ancient Sage" is the Athenian statesman Themistocles, who, according to Plutarch, said that he could not play the lyre but knew how to make a small city great. "Shewn" is an old spelling of shown; "requisition" means a formal request. Bracketed ellipses mark omitted rules, and Franklin's italics are not reproduced. Text from Benjamin Franklin: Representative Selections (1936), Project Gutenberg eBook #35508.

Question 1 of 4

The comparison of an empire to "a great cake" in paragraph 3, which the speaker extends in paragraph 4 with the "wise ginger-bread-baker," primarily serves to

Question 2 of 4

In paragraph 5, the comparison to "the husband who uses his wife ill from suspicion" most directly supports which claim implicit in the passage?

Paragraph 1
(1) Most ninth graders aren't thinking about saving money for the future, and that's understandable. (2) Retirement is fifty years away, and even college can feel distant when you're fourteen. (3) But the earlier you start saving, the more your money can grow on its own. (4) The reason is compound interest. (5) Compound interest is defined as the addition of interest to the principal sum of a deposit, such that interest is earned on previously accumulated interest.
Paragraph 2
(6) For example, if you put $100 in an account that earns 5 percent a year, you'll have $105 after one year. (7) The next year, you earn 5 percent on $105, not just on the original $100. (8) After ten years, your $100 will have grown to about $163 without your adding another cent. (9) Compound interest is like the logistic growth curve in a population ecology model. (10) The longer your money sits, the faster it grows.
Paragraph 3
(11) Time matters even more than the amount you start with. (12) Imagine two friends who each save $25 a month in accounts that earn 5 percent a year. (13) One starts at fifteen, and the other waits until twenty-five. (14) If both keep saving until they turn sixty-five, the friend who started first will end up with far more, and most of the difference will come from interest, not from her extra deposits. (15) That ten-year head start is something no one can buy back later.
Paragraph 4
(16) You don't need a lot of money to begin. (17) Many banks let teenagers open a savings account with a parent, sometimes with as little as $25. (18) Even saving the cost of one snack a week adds up over a few years. (19) A parent or guardian can help you compare the options at a few local banks. (20) So even a small amount saved now can matter later.

Written for this practice set: a student's draft of an article for a newsletter read by the school's ninth graders. The interest examples assume the interest is added once a year.

Question 3 of 4

The writer wants to replace sentence 9 with a comparison that will help this audience understand how compound interest works. Which sentence best accomplishes this goal?

Question 4 of 4

The writer wants to add an example after sentence 8 that this audience can relate to. Which sentence best accomplishes this goal?

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.