Skip to main content

Unit 3 · Topic 3.2

3.2 Interactions Within and Across Cultures in Early European and Colonial American Art

Between about 400 and 1700, art moved with trade, pilgrimage, conquest and conversion. This topic covers nine works where one culture borrowed from another or from the past: Roman buildings reused by Christians, Byzantine domes copied by Ottomans, ancient sculpture revived in Florence and European forms reshaped in the Andes.

Key terms

  • basilica
  • pendentive
  • horseshoe arch
  • classical revival
  • engraving
  • syncretism

Late Antique and Byzantine borrowings

Santa Sabina (Rome; Late Antique Europe; c. 422–432 CE; brick and stone, wooden roof). When Christianity became legal, churches adopted the Roman basilica, a long civic hall, not the pagan temple. Santa Sabina has a nave (central aisle), side aisles, rows of Corinthian columns, clerestory windows and an apse (a rounded end) where the altar stands. The plain brick outside contrasts with a light-filled interior. Its carved wooden doors include one of the earliest surviving images of the Crucifixion.

Vienna Genesis: Rebecca and Eliezer at the Well and Jacob Wrestling the Angel (Early Byzantine Europe; early sixth century CE; tempera, gold and silver on purple vellum). Vellum dyed purple, the imperial color, with text in silver, marks a luxury book. The pictures use continuous narrative: one character appears several times in a single scene. Rebecca leaves the city and then gives water to Eliezer's camels, near a reclining nymph who personifies the spring, a figure borrowed from classical art.

Hagia Sophia (Constantinople, Istanbul; Anthemius of Tralles and Isidorus of Miletus; 532–537 CE; brick and ceramic elements with stone and mosaic veneer). The emperor Justinian rebuilt it after riots destroyed the earlier church. Its architects were mathematicians and engineers. A huge dome rests on pendentives, curved triangles that turn a square base into a circle, and a ring of 40 windows at its base makes it seem to float. After the Ottoman conquest in 1453, it became a mosque. Minarets were added, and much later, in the 1800s, the huge calligraphy roundels.

Islamic Spain and the Ottoman Empire

Great Mosque (Córdoba, Spain; Umayyad; c. 785–786 CE; stone masonry). Abd al-Rahman I, an Umayyad prince who escaped Syria when his dynasty was overthrown, founded it. It is a hypostyle hall, a prayer space filled with columns. Many columns were reused from Roman and Visigothic buildings, and because they were short, builders stacked two tiers of arches to raise the roof. The lower arches are horseshoe-shaped, and the arches use alternating red brick and white stone. A later caliph added a mihrab (the niche showing the direction of prayer) decorated with mosaics by craftsmen sent from Byzantium. After the Christian conquest, a cathedral was built inside.

Mosque of Selim II (Edirne, Turkey; Sinan; 1568–1575; brick and stone). Sinan, the chief Ottoman architect, set a huge dome on eight piers, creating one open, light-filled space. He aimed to rival Hagia Sophia's dome. Four very tall, slender minarets frame it, and Iznik tiles decorate the interior.

Reviving antiquity in Italy and Germany

David (Donatello; c. 1440–1460; bronze). The first freestanding life-size nude male statue since antiquity. David stands in contrapposto, wearing only a hat and boots, his foot on Goliath's head. He was displayed in the Medici family's palace courtyard. David, the small hero who beats a giant, was a symbol of Florence facing more powerful rivals.

Palazzo Rucellai (Florence; Leon Battista Alberti; c. 1450; stone, masonry). Alberti wrote a treatise on architecture based on ancient Roman writers. On this palace for the merchant Giovanni Rucellai, he layered flat pilasters in different classical orders on each floor, an idea taken from the Colosseum. The frieze includes the Rucellai sail emblem and Medici symbols, marking a marriage between the families.

Adam and Eve (Albrecht Dürer; 1504; engraving). Dürer, from Nuremberg, studied Italian ideas about ideal proportion and brought them north. His Adam recalls an ancient statue of Apollo. In engraving, the artist cuts lines into a metal plate with a sharp tool called a burin, inks the plate and prints it, so the image can travel widely. A sign on a branch proudly gives his name in Latin. The animals may stand for the four humors (cat, rabbit, ox and elk), which medieval medicine said ruled personality.

The Spanish colonies

Angel with Arquebus, Asiel Timor Dei (Master of Calamarca, La Paz School; c. 17th century; oil on canvas). Painted in the Andes, in today's Bolivia, this angel wears the lace and rich clothing of a Spanish nobleman and handles an arquebus, an early gun, in a pose likely copied from a European military manual. Angels like this appealed to Indigenous converts, perhaps because of older Andean beliefs about powerful beings in the sky. The blend of European Christian imagery and local meaning is called syncretism.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Explaining cross-cultural influence

    Explain how Sinan's Mosque of Selim II responds to Hagia Sophia.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Identify both works with identifiers.
    2. Step 2: Name the shared feature: a vast central dome over an open interior.
    3. Step 3: Explain the difference: Sinan's eight-pier support and many windows create a more unified space; minarets frame the exterior.
    4. Step 4: Explain why: Ottoman rulers who had taken Constantinople wanted mosques that equaled or surpassed its greatest building.

    Answer: Model answer: Hagia Sophia (532–537 CE) became a mosque after the Ottomans took Constantinople, and its huge dome set the standard Ottoman architects measured themselves against. In the Mosque of Selim II (1568–1575), Sinan also centered the building on a vast dome, but he raised it on eight piers so the prayer hall is one open, evenly lit space, without the side aisles and galleries of Hagia Sophia. By matching the Byzantine dome in scale, Sinan showed that the Ottoman sultan's mosque could rival the most famous church of the empire it had conquered.

Common mistakes

  • Calling pendentives squinches, or describing Hagia Sophia's dome as resting on a drum. Know the pendentive: a curved triangle linking square to circle.
  • Saying the Great Mosque of Córdoba was built from scratch. Reused Roman and Visigothic columns are central to its design.
  • Forgetting that Dürer's Adam and Eve is an engraving, not a woodcut. Engraving uses a metal plate and a burin.
  • Writing about the Angel with Arquebus as purely European. The point is a European form adapted for an Andean audience.

On the exam

  • Continuity-and-change and comparison questions often use this topic: basilica to church, Byzantine dome to Ottoman mosque, ancient nude to Renaissance nude.
  • When you explain influence, name the source and the change. 'Inspired by' alone earns little; say what was borrowed and what was new.

Connected topics

Videos

  • AP Art History Required Images: Unit 3 - Part 2, Images 51, 52 || San Vitale & Hagia Sophia

    Accessible Art HistoryWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • It's a church. It's a mosque. It's Hagia Sophia. - Kelly Wall

    TED-EdWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Donatello, David

    SmarthistoryWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Exploring the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba

    Let's Talk ReligionWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • What is a PALAZZO? | Alberti’s Palazzo Rucellai in Florence

    ARTSQWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Adam and Eve, Albrecht Dürer, 1504

    ClarkArtInstituteWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 3.2 Interactions Within and Across Cultures in Early European and Colonial American Art

4 questions on 3.2 Interactions Within and Across Cultures in Early European and Colonial American Art. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Great Mosque. Córdoba, Spain. Umayyad. c. 785–786 CE. Stone masonry.Photo: Alvaro.vinuela.carnicero. CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source
A dim hall filled with rows of slender columns supporting two tiers of arches striped in red and white.

Great Mosque. Córdoba, Spain. Umayyad. c. 785–786 CE. Stone masonry.

Photo: Alvaro.vinuela.carnicero. CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source

The prayer hall is a forest of columns. On top of the columns, two tiers of arches rise one above the other; the lower arches swell outward before closing, and the wedge-shaped stones of the arches alternate between red brick and pale stone. Many of the columns and capitals were taken from older Roman and Visigothic buildings. Later rulers extended the hall several times.

Question 1 of 4

The lower arches, which curve outward past a half circle before closing, are called

Question 2 of 4

The reuse of Roman and Visigothic columns in the mosque shows

Pazzi Chapel. Basilica di Santa Croce. Florence, Italy. Filippo Brunelleschi (architect). c. 1429–1461 CE. Masonry.Photo: Armin Kleiner. CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source
A small Renaissance building with a porch of slender columns, a wide upper wall and a small dome, at the end of a long arcaded courtyard.

Pazzi Chapel. Basilica di Santa Croce. Florence, Italy. Filippo Brunelleschi (architect). c. 1429–1461 CE. Masonry.

Photo: Armin Kleiner. CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source
Palazzo Rucellai. Florence, Italy. Leon Battista Alberti (architect). c. 1450 CE. Stone, masonry.Photo: Miguel Hermoso Cuesta. CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source
A three-story stone palace facade divided by flat pilasters and horizontal bands, with paired arched windows.

Palazzo Rucellai. Florence, Italy. Leon Battista Alberti (architect). c. 1450 CE. Stone, masonry.

Photo: Miguel Hermoso Cuesta. CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source

The Pazzi Chapel, a chapter house at the church of Santa Croce, has white plaster walls marked out by flat pilasters, arches and moldings of gray stone. Its interior is a clear arrangement of squares and circles, crowned by a dome resting on pendentives.

The facade of the Palazzo Rucellai, a family palace on a Florence street, is divided into three stories by horizontal bands. Flat pilasters on each story use a different classical order, and the smooth stone is cut with lines that imitate blocks.

Question 3 of 4

Brunelleschi's design of the Pazzi Chapel reflects Renaissance architecture's interest in

Question 4 of 4

Alberti's stacking of different classical orders on the three stories of the Palazzo Rucellai was inspired by

0 of 4 answered