AP® Psychology review sheet from Aim for Five (aimforfive.com/psych/units/2/2-7)
Unit 2 · Topic 2.7
2.7 Forgetting and Other Memory Challenges
You forget fastest soon after learning and then more slowly, as the forgetting curve shows. Forgetting comes from encoding failure, interference or missing retrieval cues, and psychodynamic theorists add repression. Memories can also be wrong without feeling wrong, because of the misinformation effect, source amnesia and the reconstructive way memories are rebuilt.
Key terms
- forgetting curve
- proactive and retroactive interference
- tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon
- misinformation effect
- source amnesia
- repression (a psychodynamic idea)
The forgetting curve
In the 1880s, Hermann Ebbinghaus memorized lists of nonsense syllables (like 'DAX' and 'QEB') and tested himself after different delays. He found that most forgetting happens quickly, within the first hours or day, and then the rate of forgetting slows and levels off. Graphed with time on the x-axis and percent retained on the y-axis, the forgetting curve drops steeply at first and then flattens.
This is why reviewing soon after learning, and then again at spaced intervals, is so effective: each review catches the memory before most of it fades.
Why we forget
To keep interference straight: proactive works forward (old disrupts new), and retroactive works backward (new disrupts old).
- Encoding failure: the information never got into long-term memory. Most people can't draw the exact design of a coin they've handled thousands of times because they never paid attention to the details.
- Proactive interference: old learning interferes with new learning. Your old locker combination keeps popping up when you try to remember the new one.
- Retroactive interference: new learning interferes with old learning. After learning Spanish, you have trouble recalling the French you studied years ago.
- Retrieval failure: the memory is stored, but you can't access it without the right cue. The tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon, when you're sure you know a word and may even know its first letter but can't produce it, is a classic example.
- Repression: psychodynamic theorists believe painful memories can be pushed out of conscious awareness to protect the self from anxiety. Many researchers doubt this happens, since traumatic experiences are often remembered all too well.
When memories are wrong
Memory isn't a video recording. Each time you recall something, you rebuild it from stored pieces, your general knowledge and your expectations, and then store it again. This is called constructive (or reconstructive) memory, and it means memories can change each time they're recalled and stored again.
The misinformation effect happens when misleading information after an event changes your memory of it. In Elizabeth Loftus's classic studies, people watched a video of a car crash. Those asked how fast the cars were going when they 'smashed' into each other estimated higher speeds than those asked about cars that 'hit' each other, and a week later, more of the 'smashed' group falsely remembered seeing broken glass.
Source amnesia (source misattribution) is remembering information but forgetting where it came from. You might be sure you saw something happen when you actually heard about it from a friend or saw it in a movie.
Imagination inflation is when repeatedly imagining an event makes you more confident it really happened. Together, these effects explain why eyewitness confidence isn't a reliable sign of accuracy, and why careful, non-leading questioning matters in police interviews and therapy.
Worked examples
Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.
- Example 1
Proactive or retroactive interference?
Identify the type of forgetting. (a) Jamal switched from piano to organ; now when he plays piano, he keeps using organ fingerings. (b) Sara moved to a new house and keeps giving her old address. (c) Leo can't remember a classmate's name; it's 'right on the tip of his tongue' and he knows it starts with M.
Show the solutionHide the solution
- Step 1: (a) The newer learning (organ) disrupts the older skill (piano): retroactive interference.
- Step 2: (b) The older learning (old address) disrupts the newer information: proactive interference.
- Step 3: (c) The name is stored but he can't retrieve it, though he has a partial cue: retrieval failure, specifically the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon.
Answer: (a) Retroactive interference, (b) proactive interference, (c) tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon (retrieval failure).
- Example 2
Evaluating eyewitness evidence
Three days after a robbery, an officer asks a witness, 'Did you see the robber's gun?' even though no gun was mentioned. A week later, the witness is confident the robber had a gun. Explain this using memory research and suggest how the interview should have been done.
Show the solutionHide the solution
- Step 1: The question suggested a detail (a gun) that may not have existed. Misleading information after the event can change the memory: the misinformation effect.
- Step 2: Because memories are reconstructed each time they're recalled, the suggested gun may have been built into the memory.
- Step 3: The witness may also have lost track of where the 'gun' came from, which is source amnesia.
- Step 4: Better practice: ask open-ended questions ('Describe what the person was holding') and record the witness's first account before any suggestions.
Answer: The misinformation effect (and possibly source amnesia) likely added the gun to the reconstructed memory; neutral, open-ended questions would reduce this.
Common mistakes
- Reversing proactive and retroactive interference. Proactive: old disrupts new. Retroactive: new disrupts old.
- Treating confidence as proof that a memory is accurate. False memories can feel just as vivid and certain as true ones.
- Calling forgetting something you never noticed 'repression.' If you never paid attention to it, that's encoding failure.
- Describing the forgetting curve as a steady, straight-line decline. Forgetting is fast at first and then levels off.
On the exam
- Expect scenarios asking you to name the type of forgetting or memory error, so learn a clear example for each.
- Loftus-style studies are common in research questions; know how wording is the independent variable and the memory report is the dependent variable.
Connected topics
Videos
Check yourself
4 questions on 2.7 Forgetting and Other Memory Challenges. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.
Participants watched a short video of a man taking a wallet from a table and leaving a café. The man was not wearing a hat. Afterward, half of the participants answered a questionnaire that included the question "What color was the man's hat?" The other half answered the same questionnaire without any mention of a hat. Participants were not told that the hat question was misleading.
One week later, all participants described the man. Of those who had seen the hat question, 34 percent said he wore a hat, compared with 6 percent of those who had not.
Hypothetical experiment
The results best illustrate
Which implication of these findings is most relevant to the legal system?
Because participants were misled about the hat question, which step is most important for the researchers to take at the end of the study?
Mateo studied Spanish for three years and has just started French. When he tries to say a French word, the Spanish word often comes to mind instead. Mateo is experiencing
0 of 4 answered