Skip to main content

Unit 5 · Topic 5.2

5.2 Coherence within sentences, paragraphs and whole texts

Writing is coherent when each idea connects logically to the next: clause to clause within a sentence, sentence to sentence within a paragraph, and paragraph to paragraph across a text. The exam's writing questions often ask you to add, cut or move a sentence to keep a passage on track.

Key terms

  • coherence
  • cohesion
  • unity
  • sequence

Coherence at three levels

LevelWhat connectsExample of a break (written for this page)
SentenceOne clause to the nextThe bus was late, and the library has new chairs.
ParagraphOne sentence to the nextA paragraph about bus delays that suddenly mentions the cafeteria menu
Whole textOne paragraph to the nextAn essay that jumps from cost to safety and back to cost with no signal

Unity and coherence

Two related ideas help here. Unity means everything in a paragraph supports the same main point; a sentence that wanders to another topic breaks unity. Coherence means the connections between sentences are clear, so readers can tell how each idea relates to the one before. A paragraph can be unified but incoherent (every sentence is on topic, but they're in a confusing order), or coherent at a small scale but not unified (each sentence follows from the last, but the paragraph drifts away from its point).

You may also see the word cohesion. It refers to the visible links between sentences, such as repeated words, pronouns and transitions. Cohesion is one of the main ways writers build coherence, and topics 5.3 and 5.4 cover those links in detail.

How the exam tests coherence

The writing questions give you a draft, usually a few paragraphs long, with every sentence numbered. Questions ask things like: Should the writer keep or delete sentence 6? Where would a new sentence best be placed? Which sentence, if placed before sentence 1, would best introduce the topic? On keep-or-delete questions, each answer choice includes a reason, such as "Keep it, because it provides an example of..." or "Delete it, because it shifts the focus to..."

To answer well, figure out the writer's purpose for the paragraph first. Then ask whether the sentence in question serves that purpose and connects to the sentences around it. Interesting but off-topic information should go, even if it's true.

Repair moves

  • Cut sentences that drift away from the paragraph's point.
  • Reorder sentences so general claims come before specific support, or causes before effects.
  • Add a bridging sentence when the jump between two ideas is too big.
  • Use transitions and repeated key words to make connections visible (see 5.3 and 5.4).
  • Check that each paragraph's first sentence connects to the end of the paragraph before it.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    A writing-section style coherence question

    Practice draft (written for this page): (1) Community gardens can help neighborhoods that lack grocery stores. (2) In many such areas, the nearest supermarket is miles away. (3) A garden on an empty lot puts fresh vegetables within walking distance. (4) Tomatoes were first grown in South America. (5) Gardens also give neighbors a reason to meet and work together. (6) As a result, residents who once had to rely on corner stores can add fresh produce to their meals. The writer wants the paragraph to focus on how gardens improve access to fresh food. Which sentence should be deleted, and which sentence is out of place?

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: State the paragraph's purpose: gardens improve access to fresh food.
    2. Step 2: Check each sentence against it. Sentence 4 is a true fact about tomatoes, but it has nothing to do with access. It breaks unity, so delete it.
    3. Step 3: Check the order. Sentence 6 begins "As a result" and describes better access to produce, which is the result of sentence 3, not of sentence 5's point about neighbors meeting.
    4. Step 4: Fix: move sentence 6 so it follows sentence 3. Sentence 5 then works as a final, secondary benefit, or could be cut if the writer wants a strict focus on food.

    Answer: Delete sentence 4, because it shifts the focus from food access to the history of tomatoes. Move sentence 6 to follow sentence 3, because "As a result" refers to the garden putting vegetables within walking distance, not to neighbors working together.

Common mistakes

  • Keeping a sentence because it's interesting or true, even though it doesn't serve the paragraph's purpose.
  • Choosing an answer because it "sounds better" without checking the reason given in the answer choice.
  • Ignoring the question's statement of the writer's goal, which usually decides the answer.
  • Fixing coherence in your own essay by adding "Also" to every sentence instead of making the logical connection clear.

On the exam

  • In writing questions, read the stated goal ("The writer wants to...") before looking at the choices. The right answer serves that goal.
  • When an answer choice says "Keep it, because..." or "Delete it, because...," check that the reason is accurate. The right decision with the wrong reason is still a wrong answer.

Connected topics

Videos

  • AP English Language Exam: Multiple-Choice Writing Section

    Marco LearningWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Make Your Writing Flow | Ideas: Cohesion, Coherence, and Organization

    Writing with AndrewWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Coherence and Cohesion in Academic Writing

    EAPFoundation.comWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • The Difference Between Coherence And Cohesion In Writing

    My English PagesWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Coherence in Writing

    Mometrix AcademyWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 5.2 Coherence within sentences, paragraphs and whole texts

5 questions on 5.2 Coherence within sentences, paragraphs and whole texts. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
(1) Every spring, Hollis seniors celebrate their college acceptance letters, but few of them have ever read a loan agreement. (2) Within a year or two of graduation, many of them will sign a lease, open a credit card or take out a student loan. (3) Each of those decisions involves interest rates, fees and fine print that can follow a person for years. (4) Yet Hollis High offers no course that explains how any of it works. (5) The school board should require every student to complete a one-semester personal finance course before graduating.
Paragraph 2
(6) A personal finance course would prepare students for decisions they will face soon after graduation. (7) Few teenagers know that a $1,000 credit card balance at a 24 percent interest rate can take years to pay off with minimum payments. (8) Fewer still understand how a credit score affects the rent they will be charged or the car loan they will be offered. (9) The school’s soccer team won the regional championship last fall. (10) A semester-long course could teach these skills before students need them, not after a costly mistake.
Paragraph 3
(11) A personal finance course would help students make good financial decisions. (12) Some teachers worry that the schedule is already too full. (13) The course could replace one semester of the current elective requirement, so students would not need to give up a core class. (14) Students who want to take art, music or computer science could still fit those classes into their other three years.
Paragraph 4
(15) Critics also argue that money skills should be taught at home. (16) Many parents do teach these lessons. (17) But not every family has the time or the background to explain loan terms or tax forms, and a school course would reach every student, not only the lucky ones. (18) A required course would make financial knowledge less dependent on the family a student happens to be born into.
Paragraph 5
(19) Hollis graduates leave ready to write essays and solve equations. (20) They deserve to leave ready to manage their own money as well.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of a proposal to the school board. Hollis High is invented.

Question 1 of 5

Should the writer keep or delete sentence 9?

Question 2 of 5

The writer wants to add the following sentence to the first paragraph to illustrate the problem described there. Last year, a Hollis senior signed a phone contract without noticing that the monthly price doubled after six months. Where would the sentence best be placed?

Question 3 of 5

Sentence 20 is reproduced below. They deserve to leave ready to manage their own money as well. The writer wants to end the passage by connecting the proposal to the point about fairness made in the fourth paragraph (sentences 15–18). Which version of sentence 20 best achieves this purpose?

Paragraph 1
(1) Behind our gym sits a quarter-acre lot that no one uses. (2) It is covered in weeds, cracked asphalt and broken glass, and the gate in its chain-link fence has been padlocked for years. (3) The student council proposes turning the lot into a school garden that classes, clubs and the cafeteria would share. (4) A garden would give science classes a place to study plants, give the cafeteria fresh vegetables and students could eat lunch outdoors.
Paragraph 2
(5) Teachers have already shown interest. (6) Ms. Ortega’s biology class could test the soil, compare fertilizers and track how quickly different crops grow. (7) Mr. Dean’s culinary class could cook with the harvest, turning tomatoes and squash into dishes for the spring open house. (8) They both said they would help plan it. (9) The art club has also asked whether it could paint a mural on the wall of the gym that faces the lot.
Paragraph 3
(10) The garden would also help the cafeteria. (11) Our kitchen manager estimates that the school spends about $400 a month on fresh produce during the fall. (12) A garden would not replace those purchases. (13) It could supply herbs, lettuce and tomatoes for the salad bar in September and October, when the harvest is largest.
Paragraph 4
(14) Gardens take work, and summer is the hardest season. (15) Without daily watering, the beds could dry out in a single week of July heat. (16) The council has a plan for this problem. (17) Families could sign up for one week each. (18) The Pine Street Garden Club has offered to lend hoses and to show volunteers how to water without wasting water.
Paragraph 5
(19) The lot behind the gym has been an eyesore for as long as anyone can remember. (20) With a little work, it could become a garden.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of a proposal from the student council. The school, teachers and garden club are invented.

Question 4 of 5

Should the writer keep or delete sentence 9?

Question 5 of 5

The writer wants to combine sentences 16 and 17 so that the plan is clearly presented as the answer to the risk described in sentence 15. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

0 of 5 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.