Skip to main content

Unit 2 · Topic 2.4

2.4 Is the evidence enough?

Evidence is sufficient when there's enough of it, and it's strong enough, to support the claim. A big claim needs more and better support than a narrow one, and weak, outdated or one-sided evidence can make readers doubt the whole argument.

Key terms

  • sufficient evidence
  • relevant evidence
  • credibility
  • bias

Quantity and quality

Sufficient evidence has two parts. Quantity: is there enough of it to support a claim this size? Quality: is each piece relevant, accurate and trustworthy? A pile of weak evidence isn't sufficient, and neither is one perfect example asked to carry a sweeping claim.

Quality checks

Credibility gets extra attention on the synthesis essay, where each source comes with a short description of who wrote it and where it appeared. A study from a research group, an opinion piece by an interested party and a company's advertisement can all be useful, but not in the same way, and Unit 6 covers how to weigh them. Whatever the source, check whether it actually says what you need it to say.

  • Relevant: does it actually connect to this claim, not just the general topic?
  • Specific: does it name people, places, numbers or details, or is it vague?
  • Credible: who produced it, and do they have the knowledge and fairness to be trusted?
  • Current: is it recent enough for the question? Data on teen phone use from 2005 tells you little about today.
  • Representative: does it reflect the usual case, or is it an unusual exception?
  • Accurate: is it quoted or reported correctly, without stretching what it says?

Match the size of the claim to the evidence

How much evidence is enough depends on how much the claim promises. "Some students at my school would use a later bus" needs little support. "Every school in the country should change its bus schedule" needs a great deal. When evidence falls short, you have two honest options: find more and better evidence, or narrow the claim until the evidence you have can carry it. Qualifying a claim this way is covered in Unit 7.

Variety helps too. Three anecdotes about the same kind of person are weaker than an anecdote, a statistic and an expert's view that all point the same way.

When evidence fails

Insufficient evidence costs a writer twice. The claim isn't proven, and readers start to doubt the writer's judgment, so even the good parts of the argument lose force. That's why reading questions sometimes ask which added detail would most strengthen a paragraph, or what a writer's evidence fails to show.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    Diagnosing and fixing insufficient evidence

    Practice draft (written for this page; the survey is invented for practice): "Phones should be banned in every classroom in America. Last week, my friend got a text during a quiz and lost focus. Clearly, phones destroy students' learning." Explain why the evidence is insufficient, then revise the paragraph so the claim and evidence match.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Measure the claim: "every classroom in America" and "destroy" make it enormous.
    2. Step 2: Measure the evidence: one anecdote about one student on one day. It's relevant, but it isn't representative, and it's far too little for a national claim.
    3. Step 3: Choose a fix. Narrow the claim to the writer's own school, and add different kinds of evidence a student could actually gather, such as a class survey and a teacher's observation.
    4. Step 4: Keep the anecdote, but let it illustrate a pattern rather than stand in for proof.

    Answer: Revised paragraph: Our school should require phones to stay in lockers during class. In a survey our class ran of 120 students (practice data, written for this page), 71 said they check their phones at least once during a typical lesson. Ms. Ortiz, who teaches chemistry, says she now spends the first minutes of each lab collecting phones so students will follow safety steps. My friend's experience shows what those numbers look like: a single text during last week's quiz pulled her attention away for the rest of the period. A narrower claim, backed by a survey, a teacher's view and an example, gives readers far more reason to agree than one story asked to prove a national rule.

Common mistakes

  • Thinking more quotations automatically means stronger evidence. Three weak quotations are still weak.
  • Using only one kind of evidence, such as only personal stories, for a broad claim.
  • Leaving the claim huge when the evidence is small. Narrowing the claim is often the smartest fix.
  • Ignoring the date or source of evidence, especially statistics.

On the exam

  • Writing questions may ask whether a writer should add or delete a sentence and why. Choose the answer that names what the evidence does or fails to do for the claim.
  • In all three essays, the top of Row B requires specific evidence that supports all of your claims. A paragraph with a claim and no real evidence pulls your score down.

Connected topics

Videos

  • Evaluating a source’s reasoning and evidence | Reading | Khan Academy

    Khan AcademyWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Evaluating Evidence: Crash Course Navigating Digital Information #6

    CrashCourseWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Evaluating Arguments – How to Spot Strong and Weak Claims

    Chorus Educational K-12 ContentWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Evaluating Arguments

    Bozeman ScienceWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 2.4 Is the evidence enough?

5 questions on 2.4 Is the evidence enough?. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
(1) When our district announced that students would need forty hours of community service to graduate, the complaints in the hallway started within minutes. (2) Across the country, more and more high schools are adding similar requirements, and students everywhere seem to have mixed feelings about them. (3) Some see the hours as a chore to check off, while others discover causes they care about for years. (4) Community service is a requirement at many schools.
Paragraph 2
(5) Required service exposes students to problems they might never otherwise see. (6) When I volunteered at the Eastside Food Pantry for my sophomore hours, I met families who worked full time and still could not afford groceries. (7) One father told me that he held two jobs and still needed the pantry every Thursday. (8) That conversation changed how I think about hunger in my own town.
Paragraph 3
(9) My friends also did service hours. (10) A classmate who spent her hours at an animal shelter now plans to study veterinary medicine. (11) Another friend realized while tutoring fourth graders that he wants to become a teacher. (12) Discoveries like these rarely happen in a classroom, where students study subjects but seldom try out the work itself.
Paragraph 4
(13) A requirement only works if students have real choices. (14) A student assigned to file papers in an office for twenty hours learns little except how to watch the clock. (15) At my school, students may choose from more than sixty approved organizations or propose a project of their own. (16) Schools that let students pick from many kinds of projects, including ones they design themselves, see more students keep volunteering after graduation.
Paragraph 5
(17) Required service, then, is worth keeping, but only if students have a real say in where they serve. (18) Without that choice, forty hours become just another box to check.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of an argument essay answering the question, “Should high schools require community service for graduation?”

Question 1 of 5

A reader might object that paragraph 2 (sentences 5–8) rests on a single experience. The writer wants to add evidence after sentence 8 to answer this objection. Which choice best achieves this purpose?

Question 2 of 5

In sentence 16 (reproduced below), the writer wants to offer convincing support for the claim about schools that allow choice. Schools that let students pick from many kinds of projects, including ones they design themselves, see more students keep volunteering after graduation. Which version of sentence 16 best achieves this purpose?

Paragraph 1
(1) Every school day, Harmon High’s cafeteria throws away about 900 foam lunch trays, one for nearly every student who buys lunch. (2) Each tray is used for about twenty minutes and then sits in a landfill for centuries. (3) Over a 180-day school year, that adds up to more than 160,000 trays from our building alone. (4) The Environmental Club proposes that Harmon replace its foam trays with washable ones starting next fall.
Paragraph 2
(5) Washable trays would cut the cafeteria’s trash dramatically, since foam trays make up a large share of what the cafeteria throws out. (6) My friend’s cousin said her school switched and it went great. (7) Foam is bad for the environment. (8) Every tray we stop throwing away is one less tray for a garbage truck to haul to the county landfill, which is expected to run out of space within fifteen years.
Paragraph 3
(9) Washable trays would also save money over time. (10) The cafeteria manager, Ms. Gill, told our club that the school spends about $5,400 a year on foam trays. (11) A set of 1,000 washable trays would cost about $4,000 and should last at least five years. (12) The school already owns a commercial dishwasher, bought in 2019 for the culinary arts program, that is large enough to handle them. (13) Even after paying for the new trays, the school would come out ahead within the first year.
Paragraph 4
(14) Some cafeteria workers have told us they worry that washing trays would slow down the lunch lines, which already stretch out the door on pizza days. (15) That concern deserves a real answer. (16) Our club would be glad to help the cafeteria staff run a one-week trial in the spring, so that everyone can see how the change works before anything is decided. (17) In the end, the switch would make Harmon’s lunchroom cleaner, cheaper to run and a better example for the students who eat there.

Written for this practice set: a student’s draft of a proposal from the school’s environmental club. Harmon High and its staff are invented.

Question 3 of 5

The writer wants to replace sentence 6 with stronger evidence for the claim in sentence 5. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

Question 4 of 5

In sentence 7 (reproduced below), the writer wants to replace a vague statement with specific support for the proposal. Foam is bad for the environment. Which version of sentence 7 best achieves this purpose?

Question 5 of 5

The writer wants to add evidence after sentence 15 to answer the cafeteria workers’ concern raised in sentence 14. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?

0 of 5 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.