Skip to main content

Synthesis essay

Required personal finance course

  • Units 6 and 7
  • 6 points
  • About 55 minutes

You read six sources on one issue, including two visuals with at least one chart or table, and write an argument that takes your own position and uses evidence from at least three of the sources. On this site a data table stands in for a visual source. On the exam: Question 1 of 3, required. Section II has 3 essays in 2 hours 15 minutes and is 55% of the score; each essay is worth 6 points on the same analytic rubric (thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1). The exam is fully digital in Bluebook. Recommended: about 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then about 40 minutes to write. These times are suggestions, and you can move between the three essays.

The question and its sources

Suggested time: 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then 40 minutes to write.

A growing number of states now require high school students to complete a course in personal finance, covering topics such as budgeting, credit, loans, taxes and saving, before they graduate. Supporters see the course as essential preparation for adult life; skeptics question how much a single course changes behavior and what students give up to take it.

Read the six sources below carefully, including the introductory information for each one.

Source A (Franklin)

The following is excerpted from “The Way to Wealth,” an essay by Benjamin Franklin first published in 1758 as the preface to his Poor Richard's Almanack. In it, a character named Father Abraham gives advice to a crowd waiting for an auction of fine goods to begin, quoting sayings from Franklin's almanacs. A 'mickle' is a large amount, a 'pennyworth' is a bargain, and 'gaol' is jail.

You may think perhaps, that a little tea, or a little punch now and then, diet a little more costly, clothes a little finer, and a little entertainment now and then, can be no great matter; but remember, "Many a little makes a mickle." Beware of little expences; "A small leak will sink a great ship," as Poor Richard says; and again, "Who dainties love shall beggars prove;" and moreover, "Fools make feasts, and wise men eat them." Here you are all got together to this sale of fineries and nick-nacks. You call them goods; but, if you do not take care, they will prove evils to some of you. You expect they will be sold cheap, and, perhaps, they may for less than they cost; but, if you have no occasion for them, they must be dear to you. Remember what poor Richard says, "Buy what thou hast no need of, and ere long thou shalt sell thy necessaries." And again, "At a great pennyworth pause a while:" he means, that perhaps the cheapness is apparent only, and not real; or the bargain, by straitening thee in thy business, may do thee more harm than good. […]

But what madness it must be to run in debt for these superfluities? We are offered, by the terms of this sale, six months credit; and that, perhaps, has induced some of us to attend it, because we cannot spare the ready money, and hope now to be fine without it. But, ah! think what you do when you run in debt; you give to another power over your liberty […] Your creditor has authority, at his pleasure, to deprive you of your liberty, by confining you in gaol for life, or by selling you for a servant, if you should not be able to pay him. When you have got your bargain, you may, perhaps, think little of payment; but, as Poor Richard says, "Creditors have better memories than debtors; creditors are a superstitious sect, great observers of set days and times."

Source: Benjamin Franklin, “The Way to Wealth” (1758). Public domain; text from Project Gutenberg eBook #43855, Franklin's Way to Wealth; or, “Poor Richard Improved.”

Source B (Grant)

The following is excerpted from an article in which a high school economics teacher describes his former students, published in a state education journal.

Every spring, former students email me from college with the same kind of question. One signed up for a credit card at orientation to get a free T-shirt and now owes $1,900 at 27 percent interest. Another didn't know that her unsubsidized student loan was charging interest while she was still in school. These are not careless students. They are students who were never taught.

I keep a folder of these emails. A young man who enlisted after graduation signed a car loan at a dealership near his base without noticing that it ran for seventy-two months; he will still be paying for the car after he has stopped driving it. A young woman paid a tax-preparation service nearly two hundred dollars to file a return so simple she could have done it herself in twenty minutes. A third moved into an apartment without reading the lease and lost her deposit over a clause about carpet cleaning.

We require four years of English because adults need to read and write. Every adult also has to sign a lease, read a pay stub, file taxes and decide whether to borrow. A semester of personal finance is not a luxury; it is the one class that every single student will use, whether they go to college, join the military or start work the week after graduation.

Some colleagues argue that parents should teach this at home. In an ideal world, they would. But many of my students' parents never learned it either, and money is the subject many families find hardest to talk about. When personal finance is left to families, the students who already have advantages get one more.

My course is not a lecture on thrift. Students build a budget for a first apartment using real rents from our town, compare two car loans, and read the fine print of a credit card offer line by line. Several have told me that the most useful hour of their senior year was the day we calculated how long it takes to pay off a $2,000 balance by making only the minimum payment. At typical rates, the answer is more than a decade.

Personal finance is still an elective at my school, and most of the emails in my folder come from students who never took it. But I won't claim the course works miracles. Some students who aced every quiz in my class have made exactly the mistakes I warned them about, because knowing that a credit card charges 27 percent and turning down a free T-shirt at eighteen are two different skills. What I notice is that when those students write to me, they already know what went wrong and what to do next, and several have paid off their balances within a year. A class cannot make every choice for a student. It can make sure she recognizes a bad one.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source C (Survey): Results of a financial knowledge quiz given to 18-year-olds in one state, by whether they had taken a personal finance course

Quiz topic or survey itemTook a semester personal finance courseDid not take the course
How credit card interest builds up (answered correctly)71%43%
Gross pay versus net pay on a pay stub (answered correctly)84%58%
How a late payment affects a credit score (answered correctly)77%49%
Comparing two loan offers with different rates and terms (answered correctly)62%37%
Reported keeping a monthly budget38%31%

Source: Hypothetical data, written for this practice set.

Source D (Vance)

The following is excerpted from a column by a researcher who studies consumer behavior.

Few people oppose teaching teenagers about money. The harder question is whether a course changes what they do years later, when they are actually choosing a car loan or a credit card. Here the research is less encouraging than the headlines. A widely cited 2014 review of more than 200 studies found that financial education had only small effects on later financial behavior, and that those effects faded with time. A 2022 review of 76 randomized experiments was more hopeful, finding real effects on both knowledge and behavior, though the effects on behavior were smaller.

Part of the difficulty is that knowledge and behavior come apart for reasons a classroom cannot easily reach. A young adult with little income may know perfectly well that a payday loan is expensive and take one anyway, because the rent is due on Friday. Another may understand compound interest and still choose a new phone over a retirement contribution, because the phone is now and retirement is forty years away. Such choices are not always failures of understanding. Often they reflect real constraints, or the ordinary human preference for the present over the future.

There are still reasons a course might be worth requiring. Even small effects, multiplied across every student in a state, could add up to fewer missed payments and less costly debt. And most studies measure behavior within a few years of a course, before many young adults face their largest financial decisions. We simply know less about the long run than we would like.

What we do know suggests that how a course is taught matters as much as whether it exists. Courses in which students practice real decisions, such as comparing actual loan offers, seem to do better than courses built around memorizing terms. And short lessons that reach people at the moment of decision, such as before signing a first lease or student loan, can reinforce what a course began.

Policymakers should also be careful about what they measure. A state that adds a requirement and then reports higher quiz scores will have shown that students learned the material, which is worth something. It will not have shown that those students borrow more wisely at twenty-five. To know that, a state would have to follow graduates for years and compare their credit records, savings and debts with those of students who never took the course, and few states have tried.

The lesson is not that personal finance classes are worthless. It is that knowledge learned at sixteen is often gone by twenty-six. Financial education seems to work best when it arrives 'just in time,' close to a real decision. A required semester may help, but no one should expect it to protect young adults on its own.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source E (Ruiz)

The following is excerpted from a letter to a state legislator from a high school counselor.

I don't doubt that personal finance matters. My concern is the schedule. Students have room for only so many courses in four years. When the state adds a required semester, something else comes out, and in practice it is usually an elective: a second year of a world language, an art class, a computer science course, a semester of band. For a student trying to complete an AP sequence or a career program, a new requirement can mean dropping the class that made them want to come to school.

Scheduling is not an abstraction. At my school, a student in our nursing pathway has every elective slot filled by her junior year. When the state added a required health course two years ago, our pathway students had to choose between dropping a clinical class and taking a summer course that costs money and conflicts with summer jobs. Many chose summer school; some left the pathway.

Those students are not rare. About a third of our juniors are in a pathway or sequence that leaves them one free elective or none. When the state adds a requirement, they are the ones who lose a class they chose on purpose.

None of this means the need isn't real. I see it every year. Seniors come to my office with financial aid offers they cannot read, unsure which numbers are grants and which are loans. Last spring one student nearly turned down a generous scholarship because her award letter listed the full cost of attendance first, and she thought it was a bill. However the state chooses to teach it, students need this.

I've also watched what happens to lessons that are added to other classes. When teachers get good materials and a few days of training, they teach them well. When the lessons are simply handed down with a deadline, they get squeezed out.

If the state wants every student to learn personal finance, it should consider building those lessons into courses students already take, such as math, economics, even English, rather than adding another box to check.

I recognize the weakness in my own proposal. A finance unit inside a math or English class can be cut short when the teacher falls behind, and it may be taught by someone who has never studied the subject. A separate course at least guarantees that the material is covered by a teacher trained to cover it. If the state decides that a separate course is the better route, I would ask it to pay for that training, to give schools two years to rebuild their schedules, and to offer a free online version during the school year, so that a student in a demanding pathway is not forced to give up a clinical class or pay for summer school to make room.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source F (Advertisement)

This source is a smartphone advertisement for a 'buy now, pay later' payment app, described here in words.

A smiling teenager holds up a pair of expensive sneakers. A large price tag reads '$180' with a line through it, and beside it, in bright green letters: 'or 4 easy payments of $45.' At the bottom of the ad, in much smaller gray type: 'Late fees may apply. Subject to approval.'

Source: A visual source described in words; written for this practice set.

Suggested time: 55 minutes

Your answers are saved in this browser as you type.

Something wrong with this question?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.

The essay

6 points

Write an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether high schools should require students to take a personal finance course to graduate. In your response you should do the following: • Write a thesis that takes a defensible position on the question. • Use evidence from at least three of the six sources to support your line of reasoning. Make clear which sources you use, by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing them; you may cite them as Source A, Source B and so on, or by the descriptions in parentheses. • Explain how that evidence supports your line of reasoning. • Use grammar and punctuation that make your argument clear.

0 words · 0 / 12,000 characters

Checking scoring…

Scoring it yourself shows you the rubric, examples and a model answer. Try writing your answer first.