Synthesis essay
Required community service for graduation
- Units 3, 6 and 9
- 6 points
- About 55 minutes
You read six sources on one issue, including two visuals with at least one chart or table, and write an argument that takes your own position and uses evidence from at least three of the sources. On this site a data table stands in for a visual source. On the exam: Question 1 of 3, required. Section II has 3 essays in 2 hours 15 minutes and is 55% of the score; each essay is worth 6 points on the same analytic rubric (thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1). The exam is fully digital in Bluebook. Recommended: about 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then about 40 minutes to write. These times are suggestions, and you can move between the three essays.
The question and its sources
Suggested time: 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then 40 minutes to write.
Some states and school districts require students to complete community service to earn a high school diploma; Maryland, for example, has required service for graduation since the 1990s. Supporters say service builds citizenship and connects students to their communities, while critics say that required volunteering is a contradiction.
Read the six sources below carefully, including the introductory information for each one.
Source A (Addams)
The following is excerpted from Twenty Years at Hull-House, a 1910 memoir by Jane Addams, who founded Hull-House, a settlement house in Chicago that offered classes and services to immigrant families. Here she describes educated young people of her time. John Locke and Johann Pestalozzi were influential writers on education; Huxley is the English biologist Thomas Henry Huxley.
There is a heritage of noble obligation which young people accept and long to perpetuate. The desire for action, the wish to right wrong and alleviate suffering haunts them daily. Society smiles at it indulgently instead of making it of value to itself. The wrong to them begins even farther back, when we restrain the first childish desires for "doing good", and tell them that they must wait until they are older and better fitted. We intimate that social obligation begins at a fixed date, forgetting that it begins at birth itself. We treat them as children who, with strong-growing limbs, are allowed to use their legs but not their arms, or whose legs are daily carefully exercised that after a while their arms may be put to high use. We do this in spite of the protest of the best educators, Locke and Pestalozzi. We are fortunate in the meantime if their unused members do not weaken and disappear. They do sometimes. […]
We have in America a fast-growing number of cultivated young people who have no recognized outlet for their active faculties. They hear constantly of the great social maladjustment, but no way is provided for them to change it, and their uselessness hangs about them heavily. Huxley declares that the sense of uselessness is the severest shock which the human system can sustain, and that if persistently sustained, it results in atrophy of function. These young people have had advantages of college, of European travel, and of economic study, but they are sustaining this shock of inaction.
Source: Jane Addams, Twenty Years at Hull-House (New York: Macmillan, 1910), chapter VI, “Subjective Necessity for Social Settlements.” Public domain; text from Project Gutenberg eBook #1325.
Source B (Park)
The following is excerpted from an essay by a college first-year student about her own service hours, published in a collection of student writing about high school.
My high school required forty hours of service. I did mine the way most of my friends did: the cheapest, fastest way possible. I logged twelve hours handing out water at a 5K, ten hours shelving books at the public library, and the rest at my aunt's church rummage sale. I got the signatures, turned in the form, and never thought about it again.
My school made this easy. The counseling office kept a binder of 'approved opportunities,' most of them one-day events, and nobody checked what we actually did at a site beyond a supervisor's initials. One friend logged eight hours at a charity golf tournament, where, as far as I could tell, his job was to drive a cart full of water bottles around the course.
It wasn't all wasted. At the library, an older volunteer named Mr. Dunn showed me how the shelving system worked and told me about the summer reading program he ran for kids whose families couldn't afford camp. For about an hour I thought I might sign up to help. Then I remembered that I only needed ten hours there, and I moved on to the next signature.
I sometimes wonder what would have happened if someone had asked me to stay, not to fill lines on a form but because I was needed. I think I would have said yes.
Not everyone did it my way. My friend Leila spent all forty of her hours, and about a hundred more, at an animal shelter, and she is now studying to become a veterinary technician. But Leila had wanted to work with animals since she was six. The requirement didn't make her care; it gave her a reason to spend her Saturdays on something she already loved. For most of the rest of us, it was a box to fill.
Here is the strange part. This fall, without anyone requiring it, I started volunteering two evenings a month at a literacy program near campus. A girl in my dorm asked me to come along, and the coordinator remembered my name the second time I showed up. I don't know whether my forty hours had anything to do with it. Maybe they taught me that I could walk into a strange place and be useful. Maybe I would have gone anyway.
I'm not proud of how I did my hours, but I'm also not sure it's my fault. Nobody asked me what I cared about, or helped me find a place where my hours would matter. The requirement measured time, so I gave it time. If a school wants students to care about their communities, a form with forty empty lines is a strange way to show it.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source C (Survey): Graduates of two school districts, surveyed one year after graduation
| Survey item | District with a 40-hour service requirement | District with no requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Volunteered at least once in the past year | 48% | 39% |
| Volunteered at least monthly in the past year | 14% | 13% |
| Said service in high school helped them choose a college major or career | 21% | 9% |
| Described their high school service hours as 'mostly busywork' | 44% | Not asked |
Source: Hypothetical data, written for this practice set.
Source D (Abernathy)
The following is excerpted from an article by a high school service-learning coordinator in a magazine for teachers.
After fifteen years running our district's service program, I can tell you exactly when it works and when it doesn't. It doesn't work when the requirement is a number of hours and nothing else. Students learn to game a number. It works when students choose a problem they care about, spend real time with the people affected, and then reflect on what they saw, in writing, in discussion, or in a presentation to the school board.
Last year a group of sophomores who started out tutoring at an elementary school noticed that many of the children came to school hungry. They researched the district's breakfast program, found that most families didn't know it existed, and designed flyers in three languages. Breakfast participation at that school rose by a third. No form with forty lines produces that. But without the requirement, I'm not sure those sophomores would have walked into that school at all.
Reflection is the part schools skip most often, because it is the hardest to grade. But it is where service turns into learning. When the sophomores presented to the school board, one of them said she had always assumed hungry kids came from parents who didn't care. After talking with families, she learned that many parents worked early shifts and had never heard of the free breakfast. That change in understanding is the real goal of service, and no hour log will ever record it.
I should also admit that most projects are less dramatic. For every breakfast campaign, there are groups whose plans fall apart, whose community partner stops returning calls, or who spend a semester on a canned-food drive that would have happened anyway. Those students still learn something, though not always what we hoped, and a skeptic could fairly ask whether their hours would have been better spent on coursework. Some students also resent being told that service is mandatory, and a resentful volunteer can do more harm than good at a preschool or a nursing home.
A good requirement also needs adults. Our program pairs every student group with a teacher and a community partner, and it counts the time students spend researching and planning, not just the time they spend on site.
That kind of program is not cheap. Our district pays a stipend to the teachers who advise service groups, and I spend much of every August recruiting partners: food banks, clinics, after-school programs, the senior center across town. Smaller districts may not have the staff to do the same, and a requirement without that support quickly turns back into an hour count. We have also learned to be flexible about where service happens. Students who work or care for younger siblings can design projects around those responsibilities, and some of our best projects have come from them.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source E (Ortiz)
The following is excerpted from a letter that a high school junior wrote to her school board.
I work twenty hours a week at a restaurant, and on the days I'm not working I pick up my two little sisters from school and watch them until my mom gets home at seven. I'm not complaining. My family needs me, and I'm proud that I help. But when the counselor told me I was behind on my service hours, I wanted to ask who she thought was taking care of my sisters.
On days I'm not working, I leave school at 2:40, walk to the elementary school, get my sisters home, make them a snack, check their homework and start dinner. On work days I go straight to the restaurant and stay until we close at ten. I do my own homework on the bus and after the girls are asleep. Last winter my youngest sister had pneumonia, and I missed a week of school so my mom wouldn't lose her job. When the counselor suggested I volunteer on Saturdays, I explained that Saturday is my longest shift.
I know some students cut corners. A friend of mine got hours for 'helping' at her uncle's car wash, which mostly meant standing around. But the rule as it is now gives her credit and gives me nothing, even though I'm doing real work every day for people who depend on me.
I can see what the requirement is trying to do. My friend Daniela didn't want to do her hours either, but she ended up translating for Spanish-speaking patients at a free clinic, and now she wants to be a nurse. I don't think she would have gone there on her own. And I understand that helping strangers is different from helping your own family, and that the school wants us to see past our own front doors. So I'm not asking the board to throw out the rule.
I've read that some districts count family caregiving, or a job that serves the public, as long as the student writes about what she learned. I would gladly write about what it's like to help raise two kids while you're still a kid yourself.
The board might worry that students would abuse a rule like that, and some might. But it wouldn't be hard to check. My manager could sign a form, my mom's work schedule is posted every week, and a teacher could read what we write and decide whether it shows real responsibility. That's more checking than my friend got at the car wash, and I'd be glad to show the board my own schedule from any week this year.
If the board keeps the requirement, it should count the work students already do for their families and neighbors. Otherwise it's a requirement that's easy for students with free time and hard for everyone else.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source F (Poster)
This source is a poster from a high school hallway, described here in words.
At the top, in bold red letters: 'HOURS DUE MAY 1!' Below is a large thermometer marked from 0 to 40 hours, with only the bottom quarter filled in. Beside it stand three small clip-art figures, one holding a rake, one holding a soup ladle and one holding a clipboard. At the bottom, in smaller type: 'Get your signatures. Turn in your log. No log, no diploma.'
Source: A visual source described in words; written for this practice set.
Suggested time: 55 minutes
Your answers are saved in this browser as you type.
The essay
6 pointsWrite an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether high schools should require community service for graduation. In your response you should do the following: • Write a thesis that takes a defensible position on the question. • Use evidence from at least three of the six sources to support your line of reasoning. Make clear which sources you use, by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing them; you may cite them as Source A, Source B and so on, or by the descriptions in parentheses. • Explain how that evidence supports your line of reasoning. • Use grammar and punctuation that make your argument clear.
0 words · 0 / 12,000 characters
Checking scoring…
Scoring it yourself shows you the rubric, examples and a model answer. Try writing your answer first.