Skip to main content

Synthesis essay

Car-free downtown streets

  • Units 6 and 9
  • 6 points
  • About 55 minutes

You read six sources on one issue, including two visuals with at least one chart or table, and write an argument that takes your own position and uses evidence from at least three of the sources. On this site a data table stands in for a visual source. On the exam: Question 1 of 3, required. Section II has 3 essays in 2 hours 15 minutes and is 55% of the score; each essay is worth 6 points on the same analytic rubric (thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1). The exam is fully digital in Bluebook. Recommended: about 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then about 40 minutes to write. These times are suggestions, and you can move between the three essays.

The question and its sources

Suggested time: 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then 40 minutes to write.

Some cities have closed parts of their downtown streets to cars, turning them into pedestrian plazas or car-free zones, at least on weekends. Supporters say the changes make streets safer and livelier; critics worry about businesses, access for people who can't walk far, and traffic on nearby streets.

Read the six sources below carefully, including the introductory information for each one.

Source A (Adeyemi)

The following is excerpted from a column by an urban planner in a city magazine.

Downtown streets are the most valuable public space most cities own, and we have handed most of that space to cars that are either parked or passing through. When cities give some of it back to people, the results are often striking: more foot traffic, more outdoor dining, fewer crashes, and streets where children and older adults can walk without fear.

People on foot also shop differently. A driver heading somewhere else passes a dozen shops at thirty miles an hour. A pedestrian sees every window. Several studies of shopping streets have found that people who arrive on foot or by bike tend to spend less per visit than drivers but visit more often, so over a month they spend about as much or more.

That does not mean every shop gains. A store whose customers load heavy goods, or whose business depends on quick stops, may lose sales on a car-free block, and cities should not pretend otherwise. Loading zones at the ends of a plaza, delivery hours before noon and short-term parking on cross streets can soften that loss. A city that closes a street without them is not following the evidence; it is ignoring the part it finds inconvenient.

The safety case is just as strong. On a busy downtown street, people on foot and people in cars cross paths constantly: at corners, between parked cars, at driveways and loading zones. Each of those moments is a chance for a crash, and the person who loses is almost always the one on foot. Take away the through traffic and most of those moments disappear.

Critics often say the traffic will simply move to the next street over. Some of it does, and neighbors are right to watch for it. But transportation researchers have also documented what is sometimes called traffic evaporation: when road space is removed, part of the traffic that used it never reappears elsewhere, because some drivers change their routes, their timing or the way they travel. The effect varies widely from city to city, and it is rarely immediate. Either way, a city should count cars on nearby streets before and after a closure instead of guessing.

Car-free streets do not have to be permanent at first. Many cities begin with weekend closures, count the results and adjust. That is how planning should work: test, measure and fix, rather than argue forever about what might happen. A weekend pilot also lets a city learn cheaply. Planters, paint and folding tables cost a fraction of new pavement, and if a plaza fails, the street can reopen on Monday morning.

A car-free downtown is not a war on cars. It is a decision that the heart of a city should be built for the people who are in it, not the people driving through it.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source B (Kowalski)

The following is excerpted from comments by the owner of a hardware store at a city council hearing.

I have sold hardware on Main Street for thirty-one years. My customers buy bags of mulch, cans of paint, lumber cut to length. Nobody carries forty pounds of potting soil three blocks to a bus stop. Since the city closed our block to cars on weekends, my Saturday sales are down by a third.

Saturday used to be my best day of the week. Contractors work Monday through Friday on other people's jobs; Saturday is when the homeowner finally tackles the deck or the bathroom, and that homeowner wants everything in one trip. I employ seven people, four of them full time, and I've already cut a part-timer's Saturday shift.

I've been told the plaza brings more people downtown, and I believe it. I see them walk past my window with coffee cups. But nobody shops for a new faucet on a Saturday afternoon stroll. My customers are contractors, landlords and homeowners in the middle of a project. They need to pull up, load the truck and go.

I'll give the plaza its due. The block is safer than it was. Over the years I've seen two people knocked down by cars backing out of the angled spaces in front of my store, and nobody has to worry about that on a Saturday now. My grandkids like it out there, too. I'm not asking anybody to go back to exactly the way things were.

I asked the city for two loading spaces at the end of the block. I was told they would 'undermine the pedestrian experience.' So now my customers park four blocks away, or they drive to the big-box store out on the highway, where parking is never a problem. Some of them haven't come back on weekdays, either.

The answer I keep getting is that shoppers will adjust. Maybe some will. But the people who adjust fastest are the ones who drive to the highway, and once a customer gets used to the big-box store, he doesn't come back downtown for a handful of screws. A hardware store on Main Street survives on habit. Break the habit for two years and you may never get it back.

And I'm not the only one on the block in this position. The florist loads wedding arrangements into a van every Saturday morning. The print shop carries boxes of flyers out to customers' cars. Neither of them can do that from four blocks away.

The restaurants love the plaza, and I understand why. People sit outside, have a drink, stay a while. But a downtown is more than restaurants. If the only businesses that can survive on a car-free street are the ones selling coffee and dinner, then we will have a very pretty street that doesn't have what people need.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source C (City data): Results of a two-year weekend car-free pilot on six downtown blocks

MeasureYear before the pilotSecond year of the pilot
Weekend pedestrians counted per day8,20013,900
Restaurant and café sales (index; year before = 100)100138
Other retail sales (index; year before = 100)10086
Traffic injuries on the six blocks143
Weekend vehicles per day on two nearby residential streets2,1003,400

Source: Hypothetical data, written for this practice set.

Source D (Huang)

The following is excerpted from an opinion piece by a member of a city's disability advisory commission, writing about her own city.

I use a wheelchair, and I love a good plaza. Smooth, wide, car-free space is often easier for me to get around than a crowded sidewalk. But every plan for a car-free street has to answer a simple question: how do people get there? For a person who cannot walk three blocks from a parking garage, or whose paratransit van needs to pull up to a curb, 'just walk' is not an answer.

I want to be clear that the plaza itself is wonderful. On a good day, it is the easiest place downtown for me to meet friends, because I don't have to dodge parked cars or squeeze past café tables crowded onto a narrow sidewalk. Older residents who use walkers have told me the same thing.

Not everyone on our commission agrees with me. Some members opposed the closure outright, arguing that any loss of curb access is a step backward for people who cannot walk far. I don't share that view, but I understand where it comes from: for a person whose van needs a curb, a beautiful plaza two blocks away can be as unreachable as one across town.

The problem is the edges. A car-free street is an island, and an island needs a way across. That means drop-off zones close to the plaza, accessible parking within a block, and paratransit stops that don't move without notice. None of these is expensive. They just have to be in the plan before the first barrier goes up.

The design of the plaza matters as much as its edges. When café tables, planters and sandwich boards spread across the old roadway without a clear path, a car-free street can become harder to navigate than the sidewalk it replaced. Blind residents have told our commission that a street without curbs can be disorienting, because the curb was how they knew where the walking space ended. Tactile strips and a consistent clear lane cost little, but someone has to insist on them.

When our city closed its main street, the accessible parking spaces and the paratransit stop disappeared along with the cars. It took eight months of complaints before the city added a drop-off zone at each end of the plaza.

I don't think the planners who left us out were careless people. They were picturing a typical visitor, someone who could park in a garage and stroll over. That is the whole problem in a sentence. When our commission finally saw the original plan, it mentioned strollers four times and wheelchairs once, and no one on the planning team had tried to reach the plaza from the paratransit stop. Once we walked the route with them, the fixes were obvious. Car-free streets can welcome everyone, but only if disabled people are part of the planning from the start.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source E (Ferris)

The following is excerpted from a post on a neighborhood online forum by a resident of a street near downtown.

Everyone downtown seems to love the new plaza. They don't live on Linden Avenue. The cars that used to drive down Main Street didn't disappear; they came here. On weekends we now get a steady line of drivers cutting through to avoid the closed blocks, many of them going much too fast for a street where kids ride bikes. The city put up two signs and called it a day. If you're going to take traffic off one street, you need a plan for where it goes.

I've lived on Linden for twelve years. It used to be the kind of street where you could let a seven-year-old ride to the corner and back. Now on Saturdays I stand in the front yard while my daughter rides, because drivers come around the curve by the church at thirty-five or forty in a twenty-five zone. Most of them aren't from here. Their map apps send them down Linden because it's the fastest way around the closed blocks.

Last month a driver clipped a parked car's mirror and kept going. Two weeks ago my neighbor's son had to swerve his bike onto a lawn. We've asked for speed bumps. The city says it needs a traffic study first, and the study will take a year.

A few of us went to a council meeting about it. The plaza supporters had slides and photos of kids eating ice cream. We had a petition with sixty-three signatures and three minutes each at the microphone. One council member told us the extra traffic was 'a sign the plaza is working,' because it meant more people were coming downtown. Maybe so. But they're coming down my street to get there.

I'll be fair: not all my neighbors mind. The couple who run the bakery at Linden and Fourth say their weekend business has never been better, and some people like being a five-minute walk from the plaza. And Linden had speeders before the plaza, too, just not this many. But nobody on my street signed up to be the detour.

What would help isn't complicated: speed bumps, a four-way stop at the church, signs telling drivers to use Grand Avenue instead. Other cities have put in temporary rubber speed bumps over a weekend. Ours says nothing can change until the study is done, which means one more summer of watching kids dodge cars.

I'm not against the plaza. My family goes there for ice cream on Sunday nights. But it feels like the city counted all the benefits on Main Street and none of the costs on ours. If the plaza is worth doing, it's worth doing right, and that means a plan for the streets around it, too.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source F (Photographs)

This source is a pair of photographs from the city's own report on its car-free pilot, described here in words.

The left photograph, labeled 'Before,' shows Main Street on a Saturday afternoon: two lanes of slow traffic, cars parked along both curbs, and a few people walking single file on a narrow sidewalk. The right photograph, labeled 'After,' shows the same block from the same angle: café tables and planters fill the former parking lanes, and the street is crowded with people walking, some pushing strollers.

The report's caption reads: 'Main Street, reclaimed for people.'

Source: A visual source described in words; written for this practice set.

Suggested time: 55 minutes

Your answers are saved in this browser as you type.

Something wrong with this question?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.

The essay

6 points

Write an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether cities should close downtown streets to cars. In your response you should do the following: • Write a thesis that takes a defensible position on the question. • Use evidence from at least three of the six sources to support your line of reasoning. Make clear which sources you use, by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing them; you may cite them as Source A, Source B and so on, or by the descriptions in parentheses. • Explain how that evidence supports your line of reasoning. • Use grammar and punctuation that make your argument clear.

0 words · 0 / 12,000 characters

Checking scoring…

Scoring it yourself shows you the rubric, examples and a model answer. Try writing your answer first.