Synthesis essay
Limiting visitors at crowded national parks
- Units 6 and 7
- 6 points
- About 55 minutes
You read six sources on one issue, including two visuals with at least one chart or table, and write an argument that takes your own position and uses evidence from at least three of the sources. On this site a data table stands in for a visual source. On the exam: Question 1 of 3, required. Section II has 3 essays in 2 hours 15 minutes and is 55% of the score; each essay is worth 6 points on the same analytic rubric (thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1). The exam is fully digital in Bluebook. Recommended: about 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then about 40 minutes to write. These times are suggestions, and you can move between the three essays.
The question and its sources
Suggested time: 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then 40 minutes to write.
Visits to the most popular U.S. national parks have grown sharply in recent decades, bringing traffic jams, full parking lots and crowded trails in peak season. In recent years, several heavily visited parks have tested timed-entry reservation systems that limit how many vehicles may enter during the busiest hours.
Read the six sources below carefully, including the introductory information for each one.
Source A (Muir)
The following is excerpted from Our National Parks, a book published in 1901 by the naturalist John Muir, who campaigned for the creation and protection of national parks.
The tendency nowadays to wander in wildernesses is delightful to see. Thousands of tired, nerve-shaken, over-civilized people are beginning to find out that going to the mountains is going home; that wildness is a necessity; and that mountain parks and reservations are useful not only as fountains of timber and irrigating rivers, but as fountains of life. Awakening from the stupefying effects of the vice of over-industry and the deadly apathy of luxury, they are trying as best they can to mix and enrich their own little ongoings with those of Nature, and to get rid of rust and disease. Briskly venturing and roaming, some are washing off sins and cobweb cares of the devil’s spinning in all-day storms on mountains; sauntering in rosiny pinewoods or in gentian meadows, brushing through chaparral, bending down and parting sweet, flowery sprays; tracing rivers to their sources, getting in touch with the nerves of Mother Earth; jumping from rock to rock, feeling the life of them, learning the songs of them, panting in whole-souled exercise, and rejoicing in deep, long-drawn breaths of pure wildness. This is fine and natural and full of promise. So also is the growing interest in the care and preservation of forests and wild places in general, and in the half wild parks and gardens of towns. Even the scenery habit in its most artificial forms, mixed with spectacles, silliness, and kodaks; its devotees arrayed more gorgeously than scarlet tanagers, frightening the wild game with red umbrellas,—even this is encouraging, and may well be regarded as a hopeful sign of the times.
Source: John Muir, Our National Parks (1901), chapter I, “The Wild Parks and Forest Reservations of the West.” Public domain; text from Project Gutenberg eBook #60929.
Source B (Castillo)
The following is excerpted from a statement by the superintendent of a heavily visited national park, announcing a timed-entry pilot program.
On a July Saturday last year, the line of cars at our east entrance stretched four miles. Every parking area in the valley was full by 8:15 a.m. Visitors circled for hours, parked on fragile meadows, and left trash and human waste along trails that were never built for such numbers. Rangers spent their days directing traffic instead of teaching visitors about the park.
The damage outlasts the summer. Meadows that are driven on in July can take years to recover, and our botanists have mapped more than forty informal parking areas that did not exist a decade ago. Black bears have learned to work the roadside pullouts where visitors feed them, and a bear that becomes too bold around people is a bear we may eventually have to remove.
We did not choose this step lightly. For years we tried other measures: more shuttle buses, road signs announcing when lots were full, and messages encouraging visitors to come on weekdays. Each helped a little. None changed the basic math. Our main valley road was built in the 1930s for a fraction of today's traffic, and our most popular trails can hold only so many hikers before they erode.
Our pilot does not close the park. From late May to mid-October, visitors entering during peak hours will reserve a one-hour entry window. Anyone may enter without a reservation before 6 a.m. or after 3 p.m., and visitors with campground or lodging reservations are exempt. Our goal is not to keep people out of their parks. It is to make sure that what people come for, whether quiet, wildlife or a trail they can actually walk, is still here when they arrive.
The peak-hour design is deliberate. On our busiest days, roughly half of the day's vehicles arrive between 8 and 11 a.m. If we can shift some of that surge into the early morning and late afternoon, which are, frankly, the most beautiful hours in the valley, we can welcome most of the visitors who come today while ending the gridlock. The limit applies to private vehicles, not to people: visitors who arrive on our shuttles or on commercial tour buses do not need a reservation.
We know a reservation system will frustrate some visitors, and we know our neighbors in the gateway towns are worried. We will publish the results of the pilot, including its effects on nearby businesses, and we will adjust the system before making any part of it permanent.
I also want to acknowledge a fair criticism we have already heard. Any online system favors people who plan ahead and have reliable internet, and many of our most loyal visitors live in rural communities where neither can be taken for granted. During the pilot we will take reservations by phone as well as online, and we will track where reservation holders come from, so that we can see whom the system is leaving out.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source C (Park data): Peak-season averages for one national park before and during a timed-entry pilot
| Measure | Peak season before the pilot | Peak season during the pilot |
|---|---|---|
| Vehicles entering per day | 6,900 | 5,600 |
| Wait at the entrance station | 52 minutes | 9 minutes |
| Time the main parking areas filled | 8:15 a.m. | 10:40 a.m. |
| Visitors rating crowding a 'serious problem' | 61% | 24% |
| Reported wildlife–vehicle incidents (whole season) | 47 | 29 |
| Lodging occupancy in the nearest town (July) | 96% | 89% |
Source: Hypothetical data, written for this practice set.
Source D (Brandt)
The following is excerpted from an interview with the owner of a family-run outfitter and café in a town just outside a national park.
Half my customers used to be people who decided at breakfast to drive up to the park. Now they check the website, see there are no slots left, and go somewhere else. Not to my town, not to my café. My July sales were down eighteen percent.
It's not just me. The motel across the street had empty rooms in July for the first time anyone can remember, and the gas station says the same thing. When a family can't get into the park, they don't spend the day here. They go to the lake two hours south and spend their money there.
The park says you can still come in before six or after three. Tell that to a family with a toddler driving in from four hours away. The reservation system works fine for people who plan everything months ahead. It doesn't work for the spontaneous trip, and the spontaneous trip is a lot of what keeps this town alive.
My mother is seventy-eight and doesn't own a smartphone. She has been driving up to that park since before I was born. Last month she pulled up to the gate at ten in the morning and got turned away. She came back down the hill and sat at my counter for an hour before she'd say a word.
I'm not against protecting the park. I've hiked those trails for thirty years, and I've seen what a busy Saturday does to the meadows. My worry is that the people who write these rules don't live here. The park can count how many cars come through the gate. Nobody is counting how many families used to stop for pancakes on the way up, or buy a fishing license, or stay an extra night because the day went well.
To be fair, the old way wasn't great for business either. On the worst Saturdays, the traffic backed up past my front door, and people sat in their cars for an hour instead of coming in. Some of my regulars from the city stopped coming on summer weekends altogether because it was miserable. And I'll admit my Tuesdays and Wednesdays are busier than they used to be, now that the park tells people weekdays are easier. It just doesn't make up for the weekends.
People talk about the park and the town like they're two separate things. They aren't. The rangers' kids go to school with mine. When there's a fire up there, it's this town that feeds the crews.
If they want to keep the system, fine. But hold back some of the passes for people who just show up, or let local businesses sell them. Give us a way to say yes to the customer standing in front of us.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source E (Nwosu)
The following is excerpted from an article in a magazine about public lands.
Reservation systems are often described as neutral: first come, first served. But 'first' is not neutral. Popular entry windows can be gone minutes after they open online. People with fast internet, flexible jobs and the ability to plan a vacation months ahead have a head start. Families who work hourly shifts, or who live in rural areas with poor connections, do not.
Then again, the old system was not neutral either. When a park simply fills up, the visitors who get in are the ones who can arrive at dawn: people staying nearby, people without small children, people whose schedules let them wait out a two-hour line. A first-come system at the gate and a first-come system online differ mainly in which kind of advantage they reward.
National parks belong to everyone, and their visitors have long been less diverse than the country as a whole. A system that limits crowds should not make that worse. Some parks hold back a share of reservations until the day before, or use lotteries instead of a race to the keyboard. Those choices matter as much as the limit itself.
Neither alternative is free of trade-offs. A lottery treats applicants equally but makes planning harder for the family that must request time off weeks in advance, and it can reward people who enter every drawing from several devices. Holding back day-before reservations helps the spontaneous visitor but shrinks the pool for those who planned. A park will have to choose which unfairness it can best live with, and it should say plainly which one it chose and why.
Reservation systems raise a quieter problem, too: they reward familiarity. Visitors who have been to a park before know that reservations exist, when they open and which hours fill first. A family planning its first trip to a national park may not learn about the system until it reaches the gate.
So does language. A reservation page written only in English, or a gate sign that explains the system in fine print, sends a message about whom the park expects. Some parks have begun working with community groups, schools and libraries to explain reservations to families who have never visited, and even to book entry windows on their behalf. Those efforts are small, but they treat access as part of the job rather than an afterthought.
None of this is an argument against limits. Crowding damages fragile places and spoils the visit for everyone, including the visitors these systems might leave out. It is an argument for designing limits with the same care we bring to protecting meadows and wildlife. A park that is protected but open only to the well-informed has solved one problem by creating another.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source F (Cartoon)
This source is an editorial cartoon, described here in words.
A line of cars and RVs, bumper to bumper, winds up a mountain road across the whole panel. At the far end, a wooden park sign reads 'Welcome! Escape the Crowds.' In the foreground, a driver leans out of his window and calls to the driver of the next car: 'Are we in nature yet?'
Source: A visual source described in words; written for this practice set.
Suggested time: 55 minutes
Your answers are saved in this browser as you type.
The essay
6 pointsWrite an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether the most crowded national parks should limit the number of visitors through reservation systems. In your response you should do the following: • Write a thesis that takes a defensible position on the question. • Use evidence from at least three of the six sources to support your line of reasoning. Make clear which sources you use, by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing them; you may cite them as Source A, Source B and so on, or by the descriptions in parentheses. • Explain how that evidence supports your line of reasoning. • Use grammar and punctuation that make your argument clear.
0 words · 0 / 12,000 characters
Checking scoring…
Scoring it yourself shows you the rubric, examples and a model answer. Try writing your answer first.