Skip to main content

Synthesis essay

Fine-free public libraries

  • Units 6 and 9
  • 6 points
  • About 55 minutes

You read six sources on one issue, including two visuals with at least one chart or table, and write an argument that takes your own position and uses evidence from at least three of the sources. On this site a data table stands in for a visual source. On the exam: Question 1 of 3, required. Section II has 3 essays in 2 hours 15 minutes and is 55% of the score; each essay is worth 6 points on the same analytic rubric (thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1). The exam is fully digital in Bluebook. Recommended: about 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then about 40 minutes to write. These times are suggestions, and you can move between the three essays.

The question and its sources

Suggested time: 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then 40 minutes to write.

Public libraries have long charged small daily fines for overdue books. Since about 2019, hundreds of public libraries in the United States, including some large city systems, have stopped charging overdue fines, while many others still charge them.

Read the six sources below carefully, including the introductory information for each one.

Source A (Hanley)

The following is excerpted from a statement by the director of a city public library system, explaining why the library stopped charging overdue fines.

Fines brought in about $180,000 a year, less than one percent of our budget. That is a small loss, and we knew it. What surprised us was what the fines were costing. More than 20,000 cardholders, a quarter of them under eighteen, had cards blocked because they owed more than ten dollars. Many lived in the neighborhoods we most wanted to serve. A ten-dollar fine is an inconvenience to one family and a reason to stay away to another.

We did not make this decision on a hunch. Before changing the policy, we studied library systems in other cities that had already stopped charging fines, and we studied our own records. The pattern was the same everywhere: most patrons return materials on time with or without fines, and the few who don't are rarely moved by a few cents a day. What our fines did reliably was sort patrons by income. At our wealthiest branch, fewer than one card in twenty was blocked. In our two lowest-income neighborhoods, it was nearly one in three.

I won't pretend the change has cost us nothing. In the first year, the share of items returned on time slipped by about two points, and holds on the newest bestsellers now take a little longer to fill. Some patrons who used to pay a dollar and move on now keep a popular novel an extra week, because nothing hurries them. We take that seriously. But a two-point dip is a modest price for reopening the library to thousands of people, and we are answering it with email and text reminders three days before an item is due, and with extra copies of the titles that draw the longest waiting lists.

We also cleared all existing fines on the day the new policy began. That was the morning our book drops overflowed. People had been holding on to books for months, some for years, because they were afraid of what they owed. One man returned a stack of cookbooks his late wife had borrowed six years earlier. A teenager brought back a graphic novel and asked, twice, whether she was really allowed to check out another.

The lost revenue had to be made up somewhere, and it was: we trimmed our spending on printed reference sets that few patrons still use, and no branch lost an hour of service. Our staff, meanwhile, no longer spends hours every week handling disputes over a few dimes; that time now goes to story hours and homework help.

Going fine-free does not mean we stopped expecting materials back. Items more than a month overdue are billed at their replacement cost, and the bill disappears when the item comes home. Our goal is the books, not the money.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source B (Pruitt)

The following is excerpted from a letter to the editor of a local newspaper.

I have paid my share of library fines over the years, and I never once thought it unfair. A library is a shared collection. When I keep a book three weeks late, someone else on the waiting list does without it. The fine reminds me that my choices affect other people.

The library says fines shut people out. Perhaps the answer is to forgive fines for children, or to let people work them off by volunteering, rather than to tell every adult that deadlines are suggestions. My grandchildren learned to return their books on time because a quarter a day meant something to them. I worry about what we teach young people when a public institution decides responsibility is optional.

I will grant the library one point. A card blocked over ten dollars helps no one, and a child who stops coming to the library because of a fine is a loss to all of us. I would gladly have supported raising the limit for blocking a card, or capping any fine at the price of a paperback. Those are repairs. What the library chose instead was demolition.

And I am not persuaded that fines bring in too little money to matter. One hundred eighty thousand dollars is not nothing to a library that tells us every spring it cannot afford to open on Sundays. If collecting fines took too much staff time, the answer was to collect them more sensibly, not to give them up.

Then there is the question of fairness to those of us who paid. For decades, patrons returned their books on time or paid what they owed, and many did so when it pinched. Now the library has erased every old fine in a single morning. I do not begrudge any child a fresh start, but I wonder what the adult who paid forty dollars last spring is supposed to conclude, except that the rules were only for the people who followed them.

The library points out that it still bills patrons for books more than a month overdue. But a month is a long time to wait for a book you need for a class or a book club, and a replacement bill does nothing for the patron who needed that book in week two.

I raised four children on a teacher's salary, and there were years when a few dollars in fines meant something to us, too. We paid them, and we learned from them. And I wonder whether anyone has asked the people on the waiting lists. My book club waited eleven weeks last winter for a novel because, as the librarian told us, three copies were 'out and very late.' Without fines, what reason do those borrowers have to hurry?

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source C (Library data): A city library system in the year before and the year after it stopped charging overdue fines

MeasureYear beforeYear after
Cardholders blocked for unpaid fines21,4000
Items returned on or before the due date81%79%
Items more than 30 days overdue2.3%2.6%
Overdue fine revenue$182,000$0
Staff hours per week spent on fine disputes384
New library cards issued to people under 186,1008,900

Source: Hypothetical data, written for this practice set.

Source D (Lindqvist)

The following is excerpted from a blog post by an economist who studies incentives.

There is a famous study every library board should know. In 2000, two economists reported on an experiment at day-care centers in Israel. Parents who picked up their children late made teachers stay after closing. When some centers introduced a small fine for lateness, late pickups did not fall. They rose, and they stayed higher even after the fine was removed.

The researchers' explanation was that the fine changed what lateness meant. Before, coming late was a favor asked of a teacher, and parents felt guilty about it. Afterward, it was a service with a price, and many parents decided the price was worth paying.

Small library fines may work the same way. For some patrons, a dime a day is not a deterrent but a fee that makes keeping a book late feel acceptable. For others, it is a debt they cannot pay. In neither case is it doing quite what we imagine.

Economists sometimes describe this as the difference between a fine and a price. A fine is supposed to express disapproval; a price expresses only a cost. When the amount is small and the collection polite, patrons tend to hear the second message. A much larger penalty might change behavior more, but it would also deepen the problem libraries say they care about, since a patron who could not pay a ten-dollar fine could not pay a fifty-dollar one either.

The day-care study is not a perfect match for libraries. Parents and teachers knew each other, while a library patron rarely knows the person at the desk. And fines may still work for the small group of borrowers who would otherwise keep a book for months. But the study's central lesson applies: a penalty doesn't just add a cost. It changes how people think about what they are doing. A fine says, in effect, that lateness is allowed if you pay. A system built on reminders and trust says something different.

There is an awkward implication here for libraries that have just dropped their fines. In the day-care study, removing the fine did not bring back the old guilt; late pickups stayed high. If library fines turned lateness into a purchase long ago, simply ending them may not restore the sense that a late book is a burden on a neighbor. Libraries may need to rebuild that norm on purpose, for instance by telling borrowers how many people are waiting for the title in their hands, rather than assuming the old sense of obligation will return on its own.

In the end, the evidence from libraries that have actually dropped fines matters more than theory. If removing fines leads to a modest drop in on-time returns, a library has to weigh that against everyone the fines kept away. If it leads to no change at all, the fines were never doing the job we imagined.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source E (Marsh)

The following is excerpted from an interview with a high school senior about her own experience, published in a library's newsletter.

In eighth grade I lost a library book. It turned out to be under my brother's bed, and by the time I found it I owed fourteen dollars. My mom said we couldn't pay it that month, so I just stopped going. That was the year I had a big research project and no internet at home. I did the whole thing on my phone.

The worst part wasn't the money, exactly. It was feeling like I wasn't allowed in anymore. I used to walk past the branch on my way home, and I'd cross the street so I didn't have to see the librarian who used to save graphic novels for me. I know that sounds dramatic for fourteen dollars. But when you're thirteen and your mom has already told you no, it feels like the whole building knows.

My friends had the same thing happen. One girl I know owed thirty dollars because her little sister checked out a stack of picture books and they got rained on. She never went back, and she was the biggest reader I knew in middle school.

When I heard the library had gotten rid of fines, I came back mostly to see if it was true. Now I'm there three afternoons a week, using the computers for college applications. I return everything on time, honestly more carefully than before, because the people at the desk know me now.

I kind of got my job through the library, too. There's a résumé workshop on Thursdays, and the woman who runs it helped me apply to the grocery store where I work now. I wouldn't have known about it if I hadn't already been there for the computers. Last month I took my little brother to get his own card, the same brother whose bed my book was under. He checked out nine books about sharks and returned them two days early.

I'll be honest, though: not everybody I know is as careful as I am now. My cousin has had the same DVD from the library since August, and when I asked him about it he just said, 'They don't charge anymore.' So I understand why some people are worried. I just think there are better ways to get stuff back, like the emails, or the librarians actually knowing who you are.

I get that books have to come back. When the library emailed me that a book was a month late and I'd be charged the full price if I didn't return it, I found it that night. That's fair. What wasn't fair was a fine that kept growing until it was easier to stay away.

Next fall I'm going to college two hours away. The first thing I'm going to do there is get a library card.

Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.

Source F (Photograph)

This source is a photograph from a city newspaper, described here in words.

The photo shows the book-return slot outside a branch library. A hand-lettered sign taped above the slot reads 'Late? Bring it back anyway. No fines, no questions.' Below it, a metal return cart is piled so high with books that several have slid onto the sidewalk, and a library worker is stacking them into a second cart.

The caption reads: 'Returns overflow at a branch library on the first morning after the city announced it would forgive all overdue fines.'

Source: A visual source described in words; written for this practice set.

Suggested time: 55 minutes

Your answers are saved in this browser as you type.

Something wrong with this question?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.

The essay

6 points

Write an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether public libraries should stop charging fines for overdue books. In your response you should do the following: • Write a thesis that takes a defensible position on the question. • Use evidence from at least three of the six sources to support your line of reasoning. Make clear which sources you use, by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing them; you may cite them as Source A, Source B and so on, or by the descriptions in parentheses. • Explain how that evidence supports your line of reasoning. • Use grammar and punctuation that make your argument clear.

0 words · 0 / 12,000 characters

Checking scoring…

Scoring it yourself shows you the rubric, examples and a model answer. Try writing your answer first.