Synthesis essay
Later start times for high schools
- Units 2, 3 and 6
- 6 points
- About 55 minutes
You read six sources on one issue, including two visuals with at least one chart or table, and write an argument that takes your own position and uses evidence from at least three of the sources. On this site a data table stands in for a visual source. On the exam: Question 1 of 3, required. Section II has 3 essays in 2 hours 15 minutes and is 55% of the score; each essay is worth 6 points on the same analytic rubric (thesis 1, evidence and commentary 4, sophistication 1). The exam is fully digital in Bluebook. Recommended: about 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then about 40 minutes to write. These times are suggestions, and you can move between the three essays.
The question and its sources
Suggested time: 15 minutes to read the sources and plan, then 40 minutes to write.
In many communities, high school classes begin before 7:45 a.m. Some districts have moved their start times later, pointing to research on teenagers' sleep, while others worry about bus schedules, after-school activities, jobs and family routines. Some states have considered or passed laws that set the earliest time a public high school day may begin.
Read the six sources below carefully, including the introductory information for each one.
Source A (Delgado)
The following is excerpted from an opinion column by a pediatric sleep researcher in a regional newspaper.
Every fall, parents tell me the same story: a child who was a cheerful early riser at ten has become a teenager who cannot be dragged out of bed. They blame phones, or laziness. Those can play a part, but the bigger change is biological. During puberty, the body starts releasing melatonin, the hormone that signals sleepiness, later in the evening. For many teenagers, falling asleep before about 11 p.m. is genuinely difficult.
Sleep specialists recommend that teenagers get eight to ten hours of sleep a night. A student who falls asleep at 11 and catches a bus at 6:30 gets about seven at best. Repeat that five days a week and the debt adds up: slower reaction times, more trouble managing mood, and more risk on the road for teenagers who drive themselves to school. In 2014 the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that middle and high schools start no earlier than 8:30 a.m.
Some parents worry that a later bell will only mean later bedtimes, as if teenagers would spend the extra hour on their phones. The studies of districts that have made the change suggest otherwise. When school starts later, most teenagers still fall asleep at about the same time; they simply wake up closer to when their bodies are ready. The gain is not unlimited. Thirty to forty-five extra minutes a night is typical, not two hours. But for a student who has been running a sleep debt since September, two and a half to nearly four extra hours a week is the difference between surviving the morning and learning in it.
None of this means screens don't matter. A phone in bed at midnight makes a hard problem worse, and families should set limits. But telling a sixteen-year-old to be asleep by nine is like telling an adult to fall asleep at seven in the evening. Most simply can't.
I should be honest about what the research cannot yet tell us. Most studies of later start times follow a district for a year or two, and many rely on students' own reports of how long they slept, which tend to run generous. Grades, the outcome school boards care about most, usually move only a little. What moves reliably is everything that comes before learning: students arrive on time, stay awake in first period and report feeling less irritable and less sad. A drowsy student does not just retain less algebra. In my experience, she is also more likely to describe herself as hopeless. Those changes are harder to put on a report card, but parents notice them at the breakfast table.
We would never schedule a teenager's first class at 3 a.m. and then lecture them about discipline. Yet for many adolescent bodies, a 7:15 start is not so different. Moving the first bell to 8:30 will not solve every problem, but it lines up the school day with the bodies we are asking to learn.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source B (Whitfield)
The following is excerpted from remarks by a school district's transportation director at a school board meeting.
Our district runs what we call a three-tier bus system. The same buses and drivers make three runs each morning: high schools first, then middle schools, then elementary schools. That is how a district our size gets twelve thousand students to school with ninety buses instead of two hundred.
If the high schools start at 8:30, something has to give. One option is to flip the tiers and start the elementary schools first, which means seven-year-olds waiting at bus stops before sunrise in December. The other is to run more routes at the same time, which means buying buses and hiring drivers we do not have. We already have eleven open driver positions. Our best estimate for the second option is about 1.4 million dollars a year.
Flipping the tiers deserves a fair hearing, because it costs almost nothing. Young children tend to wake early on their own, and a few districts that tried it report that many elementary parents came to like a day that ends by two o'clock. But the families who object are the ones with the fewest options. A parent who leaves for a 6 a.m. shift cannot wait at the corner with a first grader, and before-school care is one more bill many of those families cannot pay. An earlier elementary day also means an earlier dismissal, which moves the same child-care problem into the afternoon.
Some board members have asked why we can't simply squeeze the three runs closer together. We studied that. Our routes are timed to the minute, and the high school runs already cover the longest distances, out to the farm roads in the north end of the county. If the first run finishes later, the middle school buses arrive late, the middle schools start late, and the elementary run is pushed back with them. Every change ripples down the line.
There are districts that have made a later start work. Most did it by spending money, by accepting longer rides for some students, or by asking more families to drive. A few partnered with a city bus system so that older students could ride public transit. Outside of town, our county has no transit system, so that option isn't open to most of our families.
I would also ask the board to remember that transportation is not only a matter of buses. A later high school schedule pushes our afternoon runs later, too, into the hours when county roads carry commuter traffic. Our drivers already work split shifts, mornings and afternoons with unpaid hours in between, which is a large part of why those eleven positions sit empty. Ask a driver to start later and finish later, and some will leave for jobs with steadier hours. The board should see the full bill before it votes.
I am not telling the board that a later start is a bad idea. I am telling you that it is not free, and the cost has to come from somewhere: from the budget, or from the youngest children.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source C (District data): One district's high schools before and after moving the first bell from 7:20 a.m. to 8:30 a.m.
| Measure | 2023–24 (7:20 a.m. start) | 2024–25 (8:30 a.m. start) |
|---|---|---|
| Average school-night sleep, self-reported | 6 hours 50 minutes | 7 hours 35 minutes |
| First-period attendance rate | 88% | 93% |
| Tardies to first period, per 100 students per week | 21 | 12 |
| Students who report dozing off in class at least weekly | 41% | 27% |
| Average GPA | 3.02 | 3.07 |
Source: Hypothetical data, written for this practice set.
Source D (Okafor)
The following is excerpted from a letter to a school board from a high school athletic director.
When a neighboring district moved its start time to 8:40, dismissal moved to 3:45. Practices that once ended at 5:30 now run until almost 7. In November that means the last hour of soccer practice happens under lights the school has to rent, or doesn't happen at all.
The bigger problem is away games. Our conference schools are spread across two counties. A 4:30 game forty miles away already pulls athletes out of last period; under a later schedule, they would miss last period two or three times a week. The students most affected would be the ones with the fullest schedules: athletes who also hold jobs or watch younger siblings.
The effects reach beyond our own players. Game officials are scheduled across the whole region, and there are already too few of them; a 4:30 game that becomes a 5:30 game competes with other conferences for the same referees. Night games add costs of their own: rented lights, custodians and the security staff the district requires at every evening event. And our smaller sports, cross-country and tennis especially, rely on parent volunteers to drive and keep time; a meet that runs past dark asks those families for a whole evening instead of an hour after work.
Athletics is not the only thing that happens after school. Our band rehearses until 5:30, the robotics team meets until 6, and the district's tutoring program uses the same afternoon hours. Every one of those would shift later, into time students now spend at jobs, with their families or on homework. A student who gets home at 7:30 instead of 6:30 has not gained an hour of sleep. She has lost an hour for everything else, and many students will make it up by staying up later.
I will grant the sleep researchers one point that coaches sometimes forget. A tired athlete is a slower athlete and, too often, an injured one. Our trainer sees more sprained ankles and pulled muscles in the weeks when students are worn down by exams, and I have watched good players fade in the fourth quarter after a week of 6 a.m. alarms. If a later start meant our students arrived at practice better rested, that would matter to me. But that benefit holds only if the rest of the afternoon moves with the bell, and no district can arrange that alone.
If the board moves forward, I would ask for two things: that the schools in our conference change their schedules together, so we aren't the only district dismissing at 3:45, and that the district pay for field lighting before the change, not after the first canceled game.
I support healthy sleep. I also know that for many of our students, what happens after the final bell is the reason they come to school at all.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source E (Reyes)
The following is excerpted from an editorial by a high school junior in her school newspaper.
Everyone assumes students want a later start, and I do. I'm writing this at 11:40 p.m. after a closing shift at the grocery store, and my alarm goes off at 5:50. But I also know what an 8:30 start would cost me. My manager schedules high schoolers from 3:30 to close. If school gets out at 3:45, I lose most of an hour every shift, about a fifth of my paycheck. And my little brother's elementary school lets out at 2:50; right now I'm the one who meets him at the bus.
I'll admit the early bell is wearing me down. Last semester I fell asleep in chemistry twice, and my first-period grade dropped from a B-plus to a C before I started drinking coffee on the bus. So I'm not someone who thinks the sleep research is made up. If anyone needs more sleep, it's the students working late shifts.
I asked around before writing this. Of the eleven people in my journalism class, seven have after-school jobs or take care of younger kids at least three days a week. That's not a scientific survey, but it isn't nothing, either. When the board held its listening session on start times, it was at 4 p.m. on a Tuesday. I was at work. So were most of the people I talked to.
I also talked to my manager, who has worked at the store for nineteen years. She said she could probably move a few of us to a 4:00 start, but not everyone, because the after-school rush doesn't move just because the bell does. Friends who work at the pizza place and the pharmacy near school heard the same thing. One manager told a friend of mine that he would rather hire college students than rearrange his shifts.
There are ways to make this work. The district could run an after-school program at the elementary schools until 4:30, so that older siblings aren't the backup plan. It could ask local employers, many of whom depend on teenage workers, to adjust their shifts. What it shouldn't do is assume that every student goes home to a quiet house and a free afternoon.
An after-school program costs money, and I know the board has already heard about the buses. But a later start that leaves working students worse off isn't really a health policy. It's a policy that helps some students rest by asking others to give up income their families count on.
I'm not saying the board should keep the early bell. I'm saying that when adults talk about 'students,' they picture one kind of student. A later start helps the student who can sleep in. It needs to help the student who works, too.
Source: Written for this practice set; the writer and publication are invented.
Source F (Graphic)
This source is a graphic from a flyer handed out by a parent group that supports later start times. It is described here in words.
Two horizontal bars sit on the same timeline, which runs from 9 p.m. to 9 a.m. The top bar, labeled 'A typical teenager's natural sleep window,' is shaded dark blue from 11 p.m. to 8 a.m. The bottom bar, labeled 'Sleep with a 7:20 a.m. start,' is shaded blue from 11 p.m. to 6:15 a.m.; the rest of the window, from 6:15 to 8 a.m., is shaded red and labeled 'Lost sleep: 1 hour 45 minutes.' A small alarm-clock icon sits at 6:15 a.m.
Across the bottom, in large type: 'Let them sleep. Let them learn.'
Source: A visual source described in words; written for this practice set.
Suggested time: 55 minutes
Your answers are saved in this browser as you type.
The essay
6 pointsWrite an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether high schools should start the school day later. In your response you should do the following: • Write a thesis that takes a defensible position on the question. • Use evidence from at least three of the six sources to support your line of reasoning. Make clear which sources you use, by quoting, paraphrasing or summarizing them; you may cite them as Source A, Source B and so on, or by the descriptions in parentheses. • Explain how that evidence supports your line of reasoning. • Use grammar and punctuation that make your argument clear.
0 words · 0 / 12,000 characters
Checking scoring…
Scoring it yourself shows you the rubric, examples and a model answer, plus sample essays scored at each level. Try writing your answer first.