AP® Psychology review sheet from Aim for Five (aimforfive.com/psych/units/5/5-5)
Unit 5 · Topic 5.5
5.5 Treatment of Psychological Disorders
Treatments for psychological disorders include psychological therapies (psychodynamic, humanistic, behavioral, cognitive and cognitive-behavioral) and biomedical treatments like medication and brain stimulation. Research shows that psychotherapy generally works, that the relationship between therapist and client matters, and that many people do best with a combination of approaches.
Key terms
- cognitive-behavioral therapy
- exposure therapy (systematic desensitization)
- person-centered therapy
- therapeutic alliance
- psychotropic medication
- deinstitutionalization
Does therapy work? Research and trends
A meta-analysis combines the results of many studies to find an overall effect. Meta-analyses of psychotherapy generally conclude that therapy is effective: on average, people who receive therapy improve more than similar people who don't. Many psychologists now use evidence-based interventions, treatments supported by research for a specific problem.
Two relationship factors help therapy work, whatever the approach. The therapeutic alliance is the trusting, collaborative bond between therapist and client. Cultural humility is a therapist's ongoing openness to learning about a client's culture and values rather than assuming they understand them.
In the second half of the 20th century, newer psychotropic medications (drugs that affect mood, thinking or behavior) helped drive deinstitutionalization, the release of large numbers of people from psychiatric hospitals into community-based care. Today, treatment is usually decentralized, delivered in clinics and private offices, and often combines medication with therapy.
Ethics in treatment
Therapists follow ethical principles set by the American Psychological Association (APA), including nonmaleficence (do no harm), fidelity (being trustworthy and keeping commitments to clients), integrity (honesty and accuracy) and respect for people's rights and dignity.
Psychological therapies
Each approach has its own idea about what causes problems and how to fix them.
| Approach | Main idea | Key techniques |
|---|---|---|
| Psychodynamic | Bring unconscious conflicts into awareness | Free association (saying whatever comes to mind) and dream interpretation |
| Humanistic (person-centered) | Help clients grow in a supportive climate; the client leads | Active listening (restating and clarifying feelings) and unconditional positive regard |
| Behavioral (applied behavior analysis) | Unlearn maladaptive behaviors using conditioning | Exposure therapy, systematic desensitization, aversion therapy, token economies, biofeedback |
| Cognitive | Change maladaptive thinking | Cognitive restructuring, challenging the cognitive triad (negative thoughts about yourself, the world and the future) |
| Cognitive-behavioral | Change both thoughts and behaviors | Rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT), dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) |
A closer look at behavioral and cognitive techniques
Behavioral therapies use conditioning (3.7, 3.8), an approach called applied behavior analysis. Exposure therapies have a person face what they fear in a safe setting until the fear fades. In systematic desensitization, a client builds a fear hierarchy (a ranked list of feared situations), learns relaxation, and then works up the list while staying relaxed. Aversion therapy pairs an unwanted behavior with something unpleasant, such as a medication that causes nausea when combined with alcohol. A token economy rewards target behaviors with tokens that can be traded for privileges. Biofeedback gives a person real-time information about body signals like heart rate or muscle tension so they can learn to control the sympathetic and parasympathetic responses tied to anxiety.
Aaron Beck's cognitive therapy helps clients spot and challenge negative automatic thoughts. Albert Ellis's REBT targets irrational beliefs ('I must be liked by everyone'). DBT, developed by Marsha Linehan, combines cognitive-behavioral skills with mindfulness and emotion regulation. Fear hierarchies cross the line between approaches: the course lists them as a cognitive therapy tool, and they are also the backbone of systematic desensitization and of exposure work in CBT.
Group therapy and hypnosis
Group therapy treats several clients at once with a therapist. Compared with individual therapy, it costs less per person, shows people they aren't alone, and lets them practice social skills and get feedback from peers. The tradeoffs are less individual attention and less privacy. Family therapy treats the family as a system, since one person's problems affect everyone.
Hypnosis can help people manage pain and anxiety. It doesn't help people dig up accurate hidden memories or truly go back to an earlier age, and it can actually make people more confident in false memories (2.7).
Biomedical treatments
Medications, summarized in the table below, are the most common biomedical treatment. When they aren't enough, other options exist. Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) passes a brief electric current through the brain of an anesthetized patient to cause a controlled seizure; it can help severe depression that hasn't responded to other treatment, with possible short-term memory loss. Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) uses magnetic pulses through the scalp to stimulate brain areas and doesn't require anesthesia. Psychosurgery removes or lesions brain tissue. The lobotomy, which cut connections to the frontal lobes, was widely used in the 1940s and 1950s and has all but disappeared.
| Treatment | How it works | Used for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Antidepressants | Many, like SSRIs, increase serotonin activity by blocking reuptake | Depression, anxiety disorders, OCD | Often take weeks to help |
| Antianxiety drugs | Many, like benzodiazepines, boost GABA's calming effect | Short-term anxiety relief | Risk of dependence |
| Lithium | Mood stabilizer | Bipolar disorders | Requires careful blood monitoring |
| Antipsychotics | Block dopamine receptors | Schizophrenia and other psychotic symptoms | Long-term use of older drugs can cause tardive dyskinesia, involuntary movements of the face and tongue |
Worked examples
Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.
- Example 1
Matching therapy to technique
Identify the therapy approach in each: (a) A therapist asks a client to say whatever comes to mind, without filtering. (b) A therapist reflects back, 'It sounds like you feel invisible at home,' and accepts the client without judgment. (c) A therapist helps a client replace the thought 'I always fail' with 'I've succeeded at hard things before.' (d) A client with a fear of elevators practices relaxation while imagining, then riding, increasingly tall elevators.
Show the solutionHide the solution
- Step 1: (a) Free association aims to reveal unconscious material, so it's psychodynamic.
- Step 2: (b) Active listening plus unconditional positive regard is humanistic (person-centered).
- Step 3: (c) Challenging and replacing a maladaptive thought is cognitive restructuring, a cognitive technique.
- Step 4: (d) Working up a fear hierarchy while relaxed is systematic desensitization, a behavioral (exposure) technique.
Answer: (a) Psychodynamic, (b) humanistic/person-centered, (c) cognitive, (d) behavioral (systematic desensitization).
- Example 2
Interpreting a treatment study
In an experiment, adults with depression are randomly assigned to 12 weeks of CBT or a waitlist. Afterward, the CBT group's average depression score is 12 and the waitlist group's is 18, on a scale where higher means more severe. The standard deviation in both groups is 8, and the difference is statistically significant (p < 0.05). Interpret the results, including the effect size.
Show the solutionHide the solution
- Step 1: Direction: lower scores mean less depression, so the CBT group improved more.
- Step 2: Statistical significance: p < 0.05 means a difference this large would be unlikely if CBT had no effect, so it's probably not due to chance alone.
- Step 3: Effect size tells how big the difference is. Cohen's d = (difference in means) ÷ standard deviation = (18 − 12) ÷ 8 = 6 ÷ 8 = 0.75.
- Step 4: A d of about 0.8 is usually called large and about 0.5 medium, so 0.75 is a medium-to-large effect.
- Step 5: Because of random assignment, the researchers can conclude CBT likely caused the improvement, for people similar to this sample.
Answer: CBT reduced depression scores compared with the waitlist (12 vs. 18). The difference is statistically significant, and the effect size is d = 0.75, a medium-to-large effect.
Common mistakes
- Tying fear hierarchies to only one approach. The course lists them under cognitive therapy, and they are also central to systematic desensitization (behavioral) and exposure-based CBT. Describe what the hierarchy does: rank fears and face them one step at a time.
- Mixing up humanistic and psychodynamic therapy. Person-centered therapy is client-led and focuses on the present; psychodynamic therapy interprets unconscious conflicts.
- Saying hypnosis can recover hidden memories. Research doesn't support this; its supported uses are pain and anxiety.
- Linking tardive dyskinesia to antidepressants. It's associated with long-term use of antipsychotics, which act on dopamine.
On the exam
- Expect scenarios that describe a therapist's technique and ask which approach it shows; free association, active listening, cognitive restructuring and exposure are the most common clues.
- If a question gives treatment data, interpret both statistical significance (is the difference likely real?) and effect size (how big is it?).
Connected topics
Videos
Check yourself
4 questions on 5.5 Treatment of Psychological Disorders. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.
| Treatment group | Mean number of steps taken toward a caged spider (0 to 10) after 6 weeks |
|---|---|
| Gradual exposure to spiders paired with relaxation | 8.2 |
| Weekly talk sessions about early childhood memories | 4.1 |
| Wait list (no treatment yet) | 2.0 |
Hypothetical experiment; 90 adults with an intense fear of spiders were randomly assigned to the three groups
The first treatment is based mainly on which approach?
What is the main purpose of the wait-list group?
Which ethical step would be most appropriate for participants in the wait-list group?
A commonly prescribed type of antidepressant, a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI), affects the synapse by
0 of 4 answered