Skip to main content

Unit 8 · Topic 8.5

8.5 Irony and complex perspectives

Writers sometimes express a complicated or ironic view through their style. Irony comes from a gap: between what is said and what is meant, or between what an argument proposes and what readers expect or value. Satirists use that gap to criticize something real, and missing the irony means missing the argument.

Key terms

  • irony
  • verbal irony
  • situational irony
  • satire
  • persona

Kinds of irony

KindWhat it isExample
Verbal ironySaying one thing while meaning something different, often the oppositeCalling a three-hour delay a "quick stop"
Situational ironyAn outcome that's the opposite of what was expectedA fire station burns down
SarcasmHarsh, obvious verbal irony aimed at a target"Great plan. What could go wrong?"
UnderstatementDeliberately describing something as smaller than it isCalling a hurricane "a bit of weather"
SatireA whole work that uses irony, exaggeration or ridicule to criticize people, institutions or ideasSwift's A Modest Proposal

How to spot irony in nonfiction

  • A shocking idea presented in a calm, reasonable tone.
  • A speaker, or persona, whose values are clearly not the author's.
  • Exaggeration so extreme that it can't be meant literally.
  • Praise that's really criticism, or criticism that's really praise.
  • Contradictions between what the speaker says and what the evidence shows.

Irony and the reader's values

Irony depends on the reader. It works when the gap between the argument and the reader's values is large enough that the reader notices it and asks, "What does the writer actually mean?" That moment of noticing is the point: it makes readers do the work of reaching the real argument, which can make them hold it more firmly.

Irony is risky, though. Readers who don't share the writer's values, or who miss the cues, may take the argument literally. Writers often guard against that with clues: a too-perfect calmness, an absurd detail or a moment where the real view slips through.

Complex perspectives without full irony

Not every complicated view is ironic. Sometimes a writer holds two attitudes at once: admiring a tradition while criticizing how it's practiced, or supporting a goal while doubting the plan to reach it. Style can signal this, for example through a respectful tone that suddenly turns dry, or through praise wrapped in careful qualifiers. Reading questions may ask you to describe such a mixed attitude, so look for answer choices that capture both sides.

Writing about irony

Identify the literal claim, explain the real claim beneath it, name the target of the criticism and explain why irony works better than direct argument for this audience. Saying "the writer is being sarcastic" isn't enough; explain what the irony reveals.

Pay attention to moments where the real view breaks through. Near the end of A Modest Proposal, Swift's narrator lists sensible reforms, such as taxing absentee landlords and buying Irish-made goods, only to dismiss them. Those are the measures Swift actually supported, and the ironic dismissal shows how often they had been ignored.

Worked examples

Try each one yourself first, then open the solution.

  1. Example 1

    The persona in Swift's A Modest Proposal

    Jonathan Swift published A Modest Proposal in 1729, when many Irish families lived in desperate poverty and much of Ireland's land was owned by landlords, many of them absentees living in England. His narrator calmly proposes that poor Irish parents sell their babies as food for the wealthy (public domain; text from Project Gutenberg): "I have been assured by a very knowing American of my acquaintance in London, that a young healthy child well nursed, is, at a year old, a most delicious nourishing and wholesome food, whether stewed, roasted, baked, or boiled ... I grant this food will be somewhat dear, and therefore very proper for landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the parents, seem to have the best title to the children." (Dear means expensive; title means a legal right to own something.) Explain how Swift uses irony to make his real argument.

    Show the solution
    1. Step 1: Find the gap: the narrator's tone is calm, polite and businesslike ("I have been assured," "very proper"), but his proposal is monstrous. That clash signals irony.
    2. Step 2: Notice the persona: the narrator thinks only in terms of economics and recipes, and never notices the horror. Swift wants readers to be horrified by his indifference.
    3. Step 3: Find the real target: "landlords, who... have already devoured most of the parents." Here the metaphor exposes Swift's real charge: landlords already consume the poor through rents and neglect.
    4. Step 4: State the real argument: the proposal is only a little more cruel than how Ireland's poor are already treated, so readers who are disgusted by it should be disgusted by the real policies too.
    5. Step 5: Explain why irony works: a direct plea for the poor could be ignored; a horrifying "solution" forces readers to feel the cruelty of treating people as economic objects.

    Answer: Model paragraph: Swift's narrator speaks in the calm voice of a policy expert, and that calm is what makes his proposal so damning. He presents a baby as "most delicious nourishing and wholesome food," reaching for a cookbook's list of methods, "stewed, roasted, baked, or boiled," as if discussing livestock. The gap between his reasonable tone and his monstrous idea forces readers to reject him, and then to notice what he is mimicking: the habit of discussing Ireland's poor purely as numbers and costs. Swift's real target surfaces when the narrator remarks that landlords, who "have already devoured most of the parents," have "the best title to the children." The joke turns into an accusation: the wealthy are already consuming the poor through rents and neglect. By making his readers recoil from a fictional cruelty, Swift forces them to recognize the real one they had accepted.

Common mistakes

  • Taking an ironic passage literally, or calling it "sarcasm" without explaining what the writer really means.
  • Assuming the narrator or speaker is the author. In satire, the persona often holds views the author is attacking.
  • Explaining the joke without naming the target of the criticism.

On the exam

  • If a passage's tone seems oddly calm about something terrible, or oddly excited about something trivial, consider irony before choosing an answer.
  • Reading questions on satire often ask about the author's actual attitude, not the speaker's. Choose the answer that describes what the author is criticizing.

Connected topics

Videos

  • Satire Explained: Analyzing Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal"

    Dr. Whitney KostersWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • What is verbal irony? - Christopher Warner

    TED-EdWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Irony | Style | Grammar

    Khan AcademyWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • "What is Irony?": A Literary Guide for English Students and Teachers

    OSU School of Writing, Literature and FilmWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

  • Situational irony: The opposite of what you think - Christopher Warner

    TED-EdWatch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Check yourself: 8.5 Irony and complex perspectives

4 questions on 8.5 Irony and complex perspectives. Pick an answer to see if you got it, and why.

Paragraph 1
An ancient Sage boasted, that, tho' he could not fiddle, he knew how to make a great city of a little one. The science that I, a modern simpleton, am about to communicate, is the very reverse.
Paragraph 2
I address myself to all ministers who have the management of extensive dominions, which from their very greatness are become troublesome to govern, because the multiplicity of their affairs leaves no time for fiddling.
Paragraph 3
I. In the first place, gentlemen, you are to consider, that a great empire, like a great cake, is most easily diminished at the edges. Turn your attention, therefore, first to your remotest provinces; that, as you get rid of them, the next may follow in order.
Paragraph 4
II. That the possibility of this separation may always exist, take special care the provinces are never incorporated with the mother country; that they do not enjoy the same common rights, the same privileges in commerce; and that they are governed by severer laws, all of your enacting, without allowing them any share in the choice of the legislators. By carefully making and preserving such distinctions, you will (to keep to my simile of the cake) act like a wise ginger-bread-baker, who, to facilitate a division, cuts his dough half through in those places where, when baked, he would have it broken to pieces.
Paragraph 5
[. . .] IV. However peaceably your colonies have submitted to your government, shewn their affection to your interests, and patiently borne their grievances; you are to suppose them always inclined to revolt, and treat them accordingly. Quarter troops among them, who by their insolence may provoke the rising of mobs, and by their bullets and bayonets suppress them. By this means, like the husband who uses his wife ill from suspicion, you may in time convert your suspicions into realities.
Paragraph 6
[. . .] VI. To confirm these impressions, and strike them deeper, whenever the injured come to the capital with complaints of maladministration, oppression, or injustice, punish such suitors with long delay, enormous expence, and a final judgment in favour of the oppressor. This will have an admirable effect every way. The trouble of future complaints will be prevented, and Governors and Judges will be encouraged to farther acts of oppression and injustice; and thence the people may become more disaffected, and at length desperate.
Paragraph 7
[. . .] VIII. If, when you are engaged in war, your colonies should vie in liberal aids of men and money against the common enemy, upon your simple requisition, and give far beyond their abilities, reflect that a penny taken from them by your power is more honourable to you, than a pound presented by their benevolence; despise therefore their voluntary grants; and resolve to harass them with novel taxes. They will probably complain to your parliaments, that they are taxed by a body in which they have no representative, and that this is contrary to common right. They will petition for redress. Let the Parliaments flout their claims, reject their petitions, refuse even to suffer the reading of them, and treat the petitioners with the utmost contempt. Nothing can have a better effect in producing the alienation proposed; for though many can forgive injuries, none ever forgave contempt.

Benjamin Franklin, "Rules by Which a Great Empire May Be Reduced to a Small One" (1773). Franklin, then living in London as an agent for several American colonies, published this satire in a London newspaper, the Public Advertiser, in September 1773, and it was reprinted that month in the Gentleman's Magazine. Its subtitle reads "Presented to a late Minister, when he entered upon his Administration." The "ancient Sage" is the Athenian statesman Themistocles, who, according to Plutarch, said that he could not play the lyre but knew how to make a small city great. "Shewn" is an old spelling of shown; "requisition" means a formal request. Bracketed ellipses mark omitted rules, and Franklin's italics are not reproduced. Text from Benjamin Franklin: Representative Selections (1936), Project Gutenberg eBook #35508.

Question 1 of 4

The speaker of the passage is best described as

Question 2 of 4

In paragraph 1, the speaker's statement that his "science" is "the very reverse" of the ancient sage's primarily serves to

Question 3 of 4

In paragraph 5, the comparison to "the husband who uses his wife ill from suspicion" most directly supports which claim implicit in the passage?

Question 4 of 4

In paragraph 6, the sentence "This will have an admirable effect every way" is ironic chiefly because

0 of 4 answered

Something wrong or out of date here?

Something wrong with this page?

What's wrong?

Please don't include personal details.